The JCF A Bloated Bureaucracy That Lacks Imagination And Effectiveness…(Part #2)

YouTube player

Only a day ago, I wrote about the state of polic­ing in our coun­try, the lack of train­ing, the lev­el of law­less­ness in our soci­ety, the lack of leg­isla­tive sup­port from the gov­ern­ment and oppo­si­tion, and the com­plic­i­ty of the judi­cia­ry in fos­ter­ing attacks on our police officers.
But that’s not all. Not only are they not paid well, but they are not giv­en the tools to do their jobs. For its part, the force has a bunch of young offi­cers who are forced out into hos­tile inner-city com­mu­ni­ties that are volatile war zones with­out back­up sup­port and, worse, with­out senior supervision.
I guess this was what Commissioner Antony Anderson was hired to do. I mean, the much-vaunt­ed trans­for­ma­tion of the Force the Prime Minister bragged that Anderson was engrossed in, and what National Security Minister Horace Chang chas­tised us for and demand­ed that “we haf­fi gi tony a chance.
This is an abject fail­ure if this is the result or even part of what a trans­formed JCF will look like.

No one should be under any illu­sion that there are not enough senior offi­cers in the force; in fact, there is an over­abun­dance of them, more than the aver­age per­son under­stands. Along with Anderson at the top of the force are, to the best of my rec­ol­lec­tion, four (4) deputy com­mis­sion­ers. There are approx­i­mate­ly thir­teen (13) assis­tant Commissioners of police… If there have been changes to the struc­ture of the 12,000-member force in that regard, I stand to be cor­rect­ed, but the num­bers would be high­er, not few­er, which goes to my point.
Additionally, the force has a pha­lanx of Senior Superintendents, Superintendents, Deputy Superintendents, and Assistant super­in­ten­dents in what is char­ac­ter­ized as the gazetted ranks.
Then there are Inspectors, the rank between the gazetted and rank-and-file offi­cers. Still, Inspectors are not gazetted, even though their uni­forms are the same as those of mem­bers of the gazetted ranks. Their caps are ringed with a red band, while the caps of the gazetted ranks are all black.
It kills me to explain this tired, old, archa­ic struc­ture that I absolute­ly hat­ed even when I served, but I believe it is impor­tant that I do so for the ben­e­fit of my readers.

So ask your­selves why, when­ev­er there are these tense moments where offi­cers are forced to deal with these law­less ele­ments, there is nev­er back­up sup­port to put down the law­less­ness, nor are any super­vi­sors rushed to the scene.
No, it’s not that they do not have the vehi­cles; they have vehi­cles to dri­ve home, so there are vehi­cles. But why are they sit­ting in offices any­way and not out on the streets doing police work?
Why are sergeants and inspec­tors at the sta­tion and not on the street? Why are super­in­ten­dents and senior super­in­ten­dents not quick­ly rush­ing to the scene like the one in the video above?
Many peo­ple now see the nice new uni­forms that offi­cers wear today. Uniforms, I might add, that I have pushed for offi­cers to be equipped with for years.
They may even think that this means the force is bet­ter than the force of the past. To that idea, I call bullshit.
This force lacks cohe­sion, train­ing, and, most impor­tant­ly, the most impor­tant ele­ment for a police depart­ment: esprit de corps.
Carolyn Gomes, a Pediatric Doctor who gained her polic­ing bona fides dur­ing pedi­atric stud­ies, con­vinced the dunces in gov­ern­ment that esprit de corps was a bad thing, a blue wall of silence that should be abol­ished. She also con­vinced them that our police lead­er­ship should come from the same morass swamp from which she emerged.

So today, the force has a bunch of P.hDs who can­not tell you the dif­fer­ence between their heads and their asses.
As a con­se­quence, the young, untest­ed offi­cers are left to fend for them­selves on the streets, damned if they do and damned if they don’t.

The following is a list of senior people the JCF has on its webpage; it characterizes them as Portfolio Officers.
This is (not) a representative sample of the number of senior gazetted officers in the Constabulary Force.
It simply means that some people are created more equal than others. Missing from this list are many other Senior officers who, though given responsibilities, do not cut the mustard as portfolio officers.

Commissioner: Antony Anderson. CD, JP, MDA, B.Eng (Hons.)
Deputy Commissioners: Clifford Blake. Deputy Commissioner of Police Strategic Operations Portfolio.
Richard Stewart, OD, M.Sc., LL.B. (Hons.), B.Sc. (Hons.), attor­ney-at-law, psc. Deputy Commissioner of Police Administration and Support Services Portfolio.
Fitz Bailey, OD, M.Sc, A.Sc, psc. Deputy Commissioner of Police Crime and Security Portfolio.
Dr. Kevin Blake, OD, PhD, M.Sc., B.Sc. (Hons.), PC Deputy Commissioner of Police Force Development and Logistics Portfolio (FDLP).
McArthur Sutherland Assistant Commissioner of Police Inspectorate and Professional Standards Oversight Bureau.
Karina Powell-Hood Assistant Commissioner of Police Staff Officer. Stephanie Lindsay, Senior Superintendent of Police Corporate Communications Unit (CCU). Gary Francis, Senior Superintendent of Police Police Emergency Communication Center.
Clifford Chambers, Assistant Commissioner of Police Area One.
Vernon Ellis, Senior Superintendent of Police St. James Divis.
Wayne Josephs, Senior Superintendent of Police Westmoreland Division. Winston Milton Superintendent of Police (Actg) Trelawny Division.
Ian Mowatt, Superintendent of Police Hanover Division.
Calvin Allen, Assistant Commissioner of Police Area Two Commander.
Dwight Powell, Senior Superintendent of Police St. Ann Division.
Lloyd Darby, Superintendent of Police Portland Division.
Bobette Morgan-Simpson, Superintendent of Police.
Glenford Miller Assistant Commissioner of Police (Acting.) Area Three.
Carlos Russell, Superintendent of Police Clarendon Division.
Shane McCalla, Superintendent of Police Manchester Division. Coleridge Minto Deputy Superintendent of Police St. Elizabeth Division.
Donovan Graham, Assistant Commissioner of PoliceArea Four.
Marlon Nesbeth, Senior Superintendent of Police St. Andrew Central Division.
Tommilee Chambers, Superintendent of Police Kingston Eastern Division.
Berrisford Williams, Superintendent of Police Kingston Central Division.
Kirk Ricketts, Superintendent of Police St. Andrew South Division.
Michael Phipps, Senior Superintendent of Police Kingston Western Division.
Gary Griffiths Assistant Commissioner Area 5 Commander.
Allison Byfield, Superintendent of Police St. Thomas Division.
Howard Chambers, Senior Superintendent of Police St. Catherine North Division
Sherika Service Superintendent of Police St. Andrew North Division.
Christopher Phillips, Senior Superintendent of Police St. Catherine South Division.

As I said ear­li­er, this list does not accu­rate­ly reflect the gazetted mem­bers of the force, which is expo­nen­tial­ly more expan­sive than those named here. So the ques­tion must be asked: With this bloat­ed bureau­cra­cy of Ph.D.s and oth­er senior lead­ers, why is the force lead­er­less like a ship with­out a rudder?
I laud every mem­ber who seeks to bet­ter them­selves by get­ting an edu­ca­tion; I do not laud those who earn degrees and then join the police force to leapfrog over real police offi­cers. Ask any of those let­tered senior lead­ers from the Commissioner to explain the laws and police pro­ce­dures and see if they know what you are talk­ing about. Worse yet, ask them how many arrests they ever made. Yes, whether you like it or not, that’s what polic­ing is about.

So, we have ultra-senior police lead­ers who know noth­ing about policing.
So, the lead­er­ship that allows this to hap­pen should all be placed in an air­plane with a per­son in a pilot’s uni­form who has nev­er flown an air­plane. That solu­tion makes sense to me. 
Why are the Jamaican tax­pay­ers pay­ing these over­weight posers to sit in offices pos­ing as lead­ers while the young offi­cers are on the streets unsu­per­vised and, worse, unsupported?
The top tier of the JCF is staffed with some peo­ple with very impres­sive job descrip­tions, yet we see none of those char­ac­ter­is­tics in their port­fo­lios trick­ling down to polic­ing for the Jamaican peo­ple who want peace and law­ful behav­ior. It must be made clear that the vira­go behav­ior we wit­ness in these police encoun­ters, par­tic­u­lar­ly from the female agi­ta­tors, is not reflec­tive of ordi­nary Jamaicans.
This behav­ior comes from a par­tic­u­lar sub­set that has been allowed to behave this way with­out con­se­quence for so long that they believe their actions are law­ful and accept­able. We need polic­ing that changes this mind­set. We need a jus­tice sys­tem with built-ins that ade­quate­ly penal­ize this behav­ior. We have nei­ther the laws nor the incli­na­tion by leg­is­la­tors to do so because, though I cringe at admit­ting it, there are law­mak­ers who are crim­i­nals and crim­i­nal supporters.
The Jamaica Constabulary Force has been trans­formed into exact­ly what Carolyn Gomes and Jamaicans For Injustice, the for­eign-fund­ed anti-police agency that pre­tends to be about crim­i­nal rights wanted.
The Force ditched Esprit de corps, cohe­sive­ness, duty, hon­or, ded­i­ca­tion, and ser­vice for a bunch of large­ly over­weight posers with more degrees than a thermometer. 
Gomes and JFJ have suc­ceed­ed where polit­i­cal inter­fer­ence failed: to destroy the morale and effec­tive­ness of the JCF. Of course, Gomes did not do it alone; she did it with the help of her for­eign han­dlers. Unfortunately for Jamaicans, the polit­i­cal lead­ers in the two polit­i­cal par­ties are too stu­pid to rec­og­nize that Gomes and what she stood for were cal­cu­lat­ed moves by her for­eign han­dlers, who want­ed the Island inun­dat­ed with crime.
Even though the JCF is now noth­ing more than a dou­ble six in a pack of domi­noes, her han­dlers are still try­ing to wreck the Island’s econ­o­my with warn­ings meant to stop tourist arrivals.
But then again, stu­pid is as stu­pid does.….…..

.

.

.

.

Mike Beckles is a for­mer Police Detective, busi­ness­man, free­lance writer, black achiev­er hon­oree, and cre­ator of the blog mike​beck​les​.com.