Police personnel at the Denham Town Police Station hold hands in prayer after their colleague, Constable Lynden Barrett, was shot and killed in West Kingston.
Whenever we hear a siren, I tell my family, “Let’s pray for whoever is in trouble,” figuring that covers anyone who has had an accident, anyone whose house is on fire, anyone who is the victim of a crime, or even anyone who has committed a crime.
The other day, a police car went by our van, and my mother said, “Let’s pray for that police officer.” I was ashamed to realise that I had never really thought about the police officers being the ones in need of prayer — but they are. When they go to answer a call, they never know what they’ll be dealing with — something small, something really awful and dangerous, or maybe nothing at all. Or it might be the last thing they do on earth. They never know.
The news is full of police officers who did their job wrong, and who abused their power. It’s a good thing to shine a light on corrupt or out-of-control police forces, and we should all know what our rights are as citizens. However, too many Jamaicans simply don’t consider the police to be on their side, and that is an intolerable state for our country to be in.
Now, along with the awful stories of corruption and brutality, we hear the occasional story about a police officer going out of his or her way to performsome extraordinary act of generosity or service, and that, too, is a good thing to shine a light on. But even these stories — the acts of extreme kindness or bravery — don’t provide the full picture of a typical day in the life of a first-responder. What’s commonplace, and which goes largely unnoticed by most of society, is that thousands of police officers do everything right every time. Everyday, they take care of thesituation, help someone out, and make the community safer. These typical days, of course, don’t make the news — but they are occasions of potential danger every single time. The police need our prayers as much as the people they are there to serve.
And what about the bad apples? They need prayer, too. Every siren should be a reminder that someone is in trouble — a victim, a perpetrator, an officer who is ready to do the right thing, and an officer who is in danger of doing the wrong thing. So next time you hear a siren, say a Hail Mary for those who are Catholics Christians or a quick “Jesus, please be with whoever needs your help” — and remember that thatincludes the childrenof God who are in uniform.
THEGLEANER published an article on October 22, 2013 titled ‘I did it for my girl’. If you remember the story, I was shot on a public passenger vehicle while trying to stop a robbery, just as Crystal Thomas was trying to do. I, however, was lucky enough to overcome my attackers and eventually killed one.
I was granted the Medal of Honour for Gallantry, which I received on October 21, 2013 at King’s House.
I urge The Gleaner to convince the Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF), and the country, that the late Constable Thomas also be granted the Medal of Honour for Gallantry, as she did, in fact, fight and save other lives that were on that bus. In fact, she made the ultimate sacrifice for the people she solemnly swore to protect as a servant of this country.
I mourn for my colleague who was not as lucky as I. May her soul rest in peace, as she died a warrior for the JCF and her country.
US President Barack Obama lays a wreath in honour of war dead at National Heroes Park in April. A correspondent has recommended that a monument to honour slain police be established at the park.
The Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF) is responsible for the safety, security and law-enforcement duties on the island nation. Numerous cops have been killed in the line of duty, and the creation of a memorial to those officers could help improve the public perception of the police.
Such a memorial park would serve to remind citizens and visitors of the risks that law-enforcement personnel take when they perform their duties, and of the responsibilities that they take on as members of the JCF.
Originally created by the British after colonisation in 1655, the JCF continues to follow the framework of the British system with regard to officer rank and some general procedures. Reorganised multiple times over the years, the police force today promotes officers from among the ranks, something that was not done previously, and actively recruits women to serve as well.
Violent outbreaks in various parts of Jamaica continue to plague the country periodically, and gang violence has also increased in recent years. Both of these challenges present the JCF with issues that can make the job more dangerous than in other countries (The History of the Jamaica Constabulary Force, 2011).
More than 30 police personnel have been killed in the three years ending in 2011; some of these were killed in the line of duty while others were killed merely for being known JCF personnel.
Just few days ago, we lost Constable Crystal Thomas, a young, hard-working and bright female cop. The simplest and least costly alternative to memorialise the slain constable, and others, is erecting a wall of honour in National Heroes Park.
Slain While Serving
Crystal-Thomas
This option has been proposed and announced on several occasions, and would list the names of those officers who have been killed. This alternative has the advantage of placing the memorial in a park that is already dedicated to honouring Jamaica’s heroes, including war heroes, as well as leaders such as Marcus Garvey.
In addition, National Heroes Park is already known islandwide, and even internationally, which provides additional publicity for the JCF memorial.
However, the park itself was considered dangerous until relatively recently, and having a police memorial erected as part of a larger park could decrease the significance of the memorial in the minds of observers.
I believe the death of Constable Crystal Thomas should give every Jamaican the motivation for a change of heart about how we view police personnel.
STCATHERINE Jamaica – Another policeman is in hospital after he was allegedly shot this morning in Spanish Town, St Catherine.The police’s Corporate Communications Unit (CCU) said the incident happened about 2:30 am and the constable is currently being treated at hospital. While CCU did not provide details on the shooting, reports reaching OBSERVERONLINE are that the lawman, who is currently on interdiction, was working as a security guard when he was shot by a firearm holder. It is believed to be an accidental shooting. The incident comes after Monday night’s shooting of a policeman during a robbery in Clarendon. He too was admitted for treatment at hospital.
Junior government minister Damion Crawford, is continuing his campaign against the Independent Commission of Investigation, INDECOM.
Damion Crawford
This time he is accusing the entity of only being interested in public relations while failing to fulfill its objectives. INDECOM was set up in 2010 to investigate actions by members of the security forces that result in death or injury to persons or the abuse of the rights of persons. However, in a series of social media outbursts in recent weeks, Crawford has attacked the agency and the authorities for allegedly only being interested in public relations. In a post on Twitter today, the East Rural St Andrew MP said INDECOM has been in the news frequently but not in relation to the conviction of bad cops. He says either there are only a few bad cops in Jamaica or INDECOM is incompetent, adding that performance is being sacrificed for public relations. In a post last week Tuesday, Crawford, the Junior Minister in the Tourism and Entertainment Ministry, said the renewal of Terrence Williams’ contract as head of INDECOM proves to him, that public relations is more important than performance. Last Monday, Williams was sworn in for a second five-year term as commissioner of the oversight body.
In 2013, Crawford called for the closure of INDECOM claiming that the entity had failed to meet its objectives. Legislators are discussing whether to establish an oversight body for INDECOM, with some critics saying the investigative body has been hampering police efforts to catch criminals. INDECOM has claimed a major role for the approximately 50 percent fall in police-related killings in 2014 when compared to 2013. Read more here. .Damion Crawford Continues Anti-INDECOM Campaign
Yet another member of the Jamaica Constabulary Force has been shot by gunmen.
The policeman, who is reportedly attached to the St Catherine Police Division, was at a bar in Clarendon last night when he was set upon by two armed robbers. According to the Corporate Communications Unit of the force, the policeman was shot once in his arm. It is understood the bullet may have lodged in his chest. The cop who is now in hospital, is reportedly in serious, but stable condition. Over the last three weeks three members of the constabulary have been shot dead by gunmen.Story originated here: http://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/news/20150804/cop-shot-robbers-clarendon
Constable Curtis Lewis Of the Westmoreland Division mowed down by a motorcyclist who ignored his command to stop . The motorcyclist accelerated hitting Constable Lewis severing his leg from his body . Constable Lewis died in Hospital. Rest in Peace Constable Lewis..
I was never ever an admiring fan of the Police High Command, those familiar with my rants are aware of my disdain for them. One of the reasons I quit the force after only ten(10) years was that I wasn’t particularly interested in aspiring to be a member of that fraternity. I was not interested in being anyone’s tool. I was not interested in taking orders which was antithetical to my oath. I was not interested in being anyone’s yard-boy. I was not interested in political affiliations for promotions. I was not interested in following behind Jamaica’s corrupt politicians(of either party) like a domesticated Mutt. And I was certainly not interested in biting my tongue when someone pissed me off.
Oh in case you are wondering about the Police High Command those were the characteristics which defined the Police High Command and they still are today. Promotions and plum assignments are tied to political allegiance and servitude. It is easy to understand why Rank and file Police officers get no respect on the streets when the top-tier of the force are mere tools of servitude.
In a report yesterday Terrence Williams made unsubstantiated allegations that Police officers are involved in making threats against his staff. Williams is the combative power-hungry Commissioner of (indecom) the police oversight agency. In what was a shocking display of recklessness Williams asserted that Police officers were involved yet produced no evidence to back up his claim. At the same time Williams made the claims, he asserted that he had a chummy relationship with the Police high command . Of course why not ? The police high command was always a bunch of cowardly rum belly lackeys who never had a problem selling out their subordinates for a pat on the back and a drink of Rum. I am still nauseated thinking about the submissive nature of some of them twenty four years later.
Constable Crystal Thomas murdered on a bus as she headed home from work..
Neither the so-called high command nor the Federation is worth a damn as far as the interest of the rank and file are concerned. It was always the young officers, gung-ho and full of bravado, who brought vitality to the force. The older members of the Federation and the high command are only interested in currying favor for promotions and special assignments. Williams asserted unequivocally, that Police officers were involved in making threats against his staff, he went as far as to nail down the age group of those he suspected. The only thing missing from William’s wild and fantastic allegations was the most important thing .…..Proof !!! Williams and his lackeys were crafty enough to placate the High command with sweet platitudes in order to win their silence ‚while he lambast and lampoon the officers who place their lives on the line for an ungrateful reprobate nation. Quote : The threats have been brought to the attention of the Police High Command, and (INDECOM) has bolstered its internal security framework and risk assessment. Williams’ assistant Hamish Campbell said quote: ” Making the incidents known to the High Command is one of the best ways to protect (indecom’s) investigators and staff. “There is coöperation with the senior police officers about it. We have discussed it, we have engaged with them,” . Of course the sell outs who head the Force never bothered to request that Williams provide proof if he intended to go public with his wild claims. And really why would they ask him to provide proof? They never cared about the younger officers and they don’t now.
Constable Lyndon Barrett.. We still do not know how this young officer lost his life and the Police high command doesn’t seem to understand his family deserves answers.
In preparing for this Article I decided to look at the webpage of the JCF . I also looked at the page of the Police Federation. as well as their Facebook pages. Despite the tragic loss of life of four (4) officers over a period of just days neither of the websites have a memorial for these officers. In fact neither their websites nor their Facebook pages provide a link to a story which speaks to the officers who fell both in the line of duty or others who died naturally or under cloudy and yet to be determined circumstances .There is no memorial in the country which honors their sacrifice but it is incomprehensible and unconscionable that neither the Police Department nor the Federation has enough common sense to honor officers with a simple memorial on their website, or on their Facebook pages.
Police corporal Tyrone Thompson… Died from supposed suicide.. To date the Police has not said definitively what the actual cause of death is. From another photograph of Corporal Thompson’s dead body many officers past and present theorized that he was murdered… The family still do not know how their loved one lost his life…
As a sign of my support for the fallen officers who give their lives for an undeserving population. As a sign of my support for the families from all across the Island who so willingly give up their sons and daughters in service to our Country this publication honors your sacrifice and commitment to our Country. As a small token of that commitment we will, starting today, begin by highlighting the last four officers who gave their lives recently. I honor and celebrate the sacrifice of all of these heroes whether the Police High Command and the Federation realize their sacrifice or not . Rest in Peace .….… It is time for members of the Jamaica Constabulary Force to refuse to carry the coffins of Ministers of Government and those the Government lift up as stalwarts within the Jamaican society. Frankly I have never seen any of those society big-wigs at the funerals of Police Officers. These are the people who clamor for (indecom) let (indecom) carry their coffins. There are many ways to opt out of those duties you are police officers. If the Country demonstrably decide it does not appreciate you then it’s time that you look out for yourselves.
Former prison escapee, Christopher “Monster” Selby appeared in the Port-of-Spain Magistrates Court today on 10 charges, including the murder of PC Sherman Maynard. Selby, 30, is the only surviving member of a trio of prison escapees who broke out of the Port-of-Spain Prison on July 24. He appeared before Magistrate Marcia Ayers Caesar in the 8th Magistrate Court. The ten charges are: murder, escaping lawful custody, possession of a firearm, committing common assault on Kerron Prime, Jean-Marc Hernandez, and Nicholas Singh, all of whom are prison officers. He was charged individually for each assault. A person can be charged with common law assault if they are threatening another person with a gun. Selby was also charged with shooting at police officers, Leon Grouse and Tishon Francis, with intent to cause grievous bodily harm armed with a firearm. The prison escapee was also charged for robbing Javid Ramcharitar of a Nissan Navara valued at $200,000.
Together with two other prisoners, armed with a firearm, he is also accused of stealing two keys for prison gates valued at $140. He was not called upon to plead to the charges. According to his lawyer Criston J Williams, Selby wanted to plead guilty to escaping lawful custody, but the police prosecutor, Inspector Winston Dillon denied his request because the Director of Public Prosecutions had to assign a state prosecutor to the case. Selby’s case was adjourned until September 1. Selby, along with fellow prisoners Allan “Scanny” Martin, 42, and Hassan Atwell, 41, shot their way out of the Port-of-Spain prison on July 24, killing Maynard as they did so and throwing the city into chaos. Maynard was shot in the front seat passenger seat of a police vehicle as he and two other colleagues were on sentry duty outside the prison. He died of his injuries while undergoing emergency surgery. Martin was killed in a shootout with police moments later at the Port-of-Spain General Hospital while Atwell was found murdered at East Dry River, Port-of-Spain a day later. Selby surrendered on July 26. Story originated here: 10 charges for prison escapee
Christopher “Monster” Selby, the only surviving member of a trio of prison escapees, will be charged for the murder of police constable PC Sherman Maynard. Selby, 30, is also expected to be charged for the daring escape from the Frederick Street, Port-of-Spain prison and several other offences. He is expected to appear in the Port-of-Spain Magistrates’ Court today to face the charges. The T&T Guardian was informed yesterday that Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Roger Gaspard met with and advised the police officers investigating the case to lay the charges against Selby. Selby, along with fellow prisoners Allan “Scanny” Martin, 42, and Hasan Atwell, 41, shot their way out of the Port-of-Spain prison on July 24, killing Maynard as they did so and throwing the city into chaos as police and the army went into lockdown mode. Maynard was shot in the front seat passenger side of a police vehicle as he and two other colleagues were doing sentry duty outside the prison. He died of his injuries while undergoing emergency surgery.
Martin was shot dead moments after he bolted, after he was cornered in the security guard booth at the Port-of-Spain General Hospital. Atwell, who went on the lam for two days, was discovered shot several times in the back and body at Calvary Hill, East Dry River, Port-of-Spain. He is believed to have been killed by members of the Rasta City gang. Selby surrendered to the police at the Barataria Police Station on Sunday. See story :http://www.guardian.co.tt/news/2015 – 08-03/monster-charged-cop%E2%80%99s-murder
There’s always a problem which needs media attention if Terrence Williams (indecom’s) Commissioner is to be believed . When he is not bitching that he needs more power to go after Police. He is bitching that he doesn’t need any oversight of the agency he heads. It’s always something with this guy , he spends so much time bitching and griping, where the hell does he find time to do his damn job? The latest coming from the infantile dictator is that his office has received death threats. I mean who gives a shit ? Even if he and his operatives received a million death threats who the f**k cares? death threats ?
Terrence Williams (right) commissioner of the Independent Commission of Investigations (INDECOM), Hamish Campbell, (centre) IDECOM’s assistant commissioner and Dave Lewis, INDECOM’s director of complaints central region at a Gleaner Editors’ Forum last Friday. (Source: jamaicagleaner.com)
How many cops lost their lives actually doing something worthwhile and commendable over the last week or two? I have just about had it with this shit head. Why not go actually do some work for the blood money you are getting paid ? In the latest in a series of attention grabbing media manipulation Williams claims “There have been threats to INDECOM staff members. The nature of the threats runs a gamut from persons making intemperate remarks, threats of what they will do, and what they will cause to be done,” Williams told a Gleaner Editors’ Forum last Friday. “It also comes in intelligence that is gathered by agencies about whisperings of plans. “The job of the INDECOM investigator is not an easy one. Apart from rogue officers or their friends who may threaten, it is also dangerous being out on the road at late hours where they have to go, because of their investigations,” added Williams. The INDECOM boss said while the threats have not been frequent, they are still matters of concern as his staff members are unarmed, and arming investigators is not an option he is prepared to explore.
HERE’S THERUB.
According to Williams, the threats have been brought to the attention of the Police High Command, and (INDECOM) has bolstered its internal security framework and risk assessment.
Williams was supported by assistant commissioner of the agency, Hamish Campbell, who argued that making the incidents known to the High Command is one of the best ways to protect (indecom’s) investigators and staff. “There is coöperation with the senior police officers about it. We have discussed it, we have engaged with them,” said Campbell. In the meantime, Nigel Morgan, INDECOM’s director of complaints for the eastern division, argued that the threats may be coming from the younger members of the force, influenced by officers at the middle-management level. “Most members of the JCF cooperate with INDECOM. It is important for us to put that on the table. There are a few, however, who will be recalcitrant; when they are given instructions they disobey,” charged Morgan. “We have reason to believe that they are being influenced by a few officers who are the middle managers, who may be anti-INDECOM,” said Morgan.
Williams claims he does not want weapons for his staff? “Yah”… If Williams wants firearms he should come out and say so . Doing the back door phycology is not fooling anyone. This guy is the worst kind of power hungry moron imaginable. ♦He wanted to be a Judge in another Caribbean Island he did not get that job. ♦ He wanted the job of Director of Public Prosecution (DPP) in Jamaica, Paula Llewelyn got the job, since then Williams has been a thorn in Llewelyn’s side claiming all sorts of incompetence on the part of her office. ♦ Since getting the job as commissioner of (indecom) he has not stopped bitching that he needs more power. ♦ Williams just lost a fight when a joint select committee of Parliament sided with the DPP that indeed (indecom) should have oversight and not be vested with super powers to go after others while the agency is not accountable to anyone. ♦ Not satisfied Williams is now back at it making fantastic claims and allegations. Let me be clear I fundamentally believe Williams and the Police high command has a chummy relationship despite his disrespect and disdain for the junior officers. The Police high command has never been anything but a bunch of lap-dogs who are willing to sell out the rank and file for a pat on the back and a drink of white Rum. Not much has changed. Insofar as this claim is concerned here’s my take .Unless Terrence Williams place evidence of the threats made against him and his lackeys in the public domain. Unless he presents proof that said threats are coming from police officers then Williams is nothing but an attention loving power-hungry lying bastard.
The Joint Select Committee of Parliament decided that (indecom)the Agency tasked with oversight of the Police Department. Military and Corrections Department should itself be subject to .… Well.. Oversight.. Well what do you know, what a Novel concept? You mean that finally the group of knuckle-heads debating this issue finally had an epiphany? You mean they are finally starting to get the simple concept of checks and balances? I mean even the Politicians are held to some degree of accountability, something which never existed before, why not (indecom)?
Craolyn Gomes
After the Contractor General’s ACT was passed many people including this writer thought , “Oh great finally some degree of accountability”. Naturally many politicians past and present were not happy with the vigilance and aggressive dedication Greg Christie the first Contractor General brought to the job. Many were happy to see the back of Christie. For the average man on the street Christie was a modern day Savior who saved tax-payers much money which otherwise would have been siphoned off through illicit and corrupt practices in the contracts awards process. Just last week a member of the Governing Administration vented his frustration with the Office of Contractor General. He claimed that the long delay of contracts being reviewed by the OCG places the Administration in a position in which it cannot carry out its mandate to create jobs.
Director of Public Prosecutions Paula Llewellyn.
A reasonable argument to make. Yet it was the corrupt practices of the politicians which made the Office Of Contractor General a necessity in the first place.
The (indecom) Act became a reality because of police officers misdeeds, as well as members of the Military and Corrections Department. Many members past and present are opposed to the Agency understandably because of their affiliations with either of the three Agencies. This writer is not opposed to (indecom) the agency . I oppose the operational tenets of the Act and I certainly am opposed to the Commissioner himself whom I fundamentally believe should not have the job as head of (indecom). Those who read my blogs are well aware of my dislike for Terrence Williams, not because he heads (indecom) but because he is on a personal crusade to persecute . I personally do not care about corrupt cops getting their just deserts. In the short ten years
Terrence Williams
I spent in the JCF I was instrumental in the prosecution and imprisonment of three corrupt cops , whom I was happy to see leave the department. So I’m certainly not an apologist as some would imagine because I do not support the wholesale persecution of good Cops. There are some people who are mentally incapable of moving past corrupt cops and embracing the value of good officers to society. Those people cannot be changed, they don’t want to change. The bad cop argument is a perfect anchor, one from which they have no desire to be unhitched.
Dennis-Meadows
The (indecom) Act is the brain-child of the abbreviated Bruce Golding Administration . The law was passed after public outcry reached fever pitch about police abuse and extra-judicial killings. The truth of the matter is that so called Human-Rights advocacy and lobbying efforts were more to be credited for the laws existence than massive police abuse. Nevertheless a phalanx of advocacy groups emerged all arrayed against the police and demanding change. Jamaicans For Justice(JFJ) headed by Carolyn Gomes a pediatric Doctor, Families against State Terrorism (FAST) headed my Yvonne McCall Sobers were just two of the advocacy groups to seriously lobby the Golding Administration for oversight of the police.
Both groups had serious backing from International Human Rights Agencies to include
Delroy Chuck
the London based Amnesty International and the Washington DC based Inter American Commission on Human Rights. Gomes and (JFJ) were instrumental in presenting false , unsubstantiated and in many cases flawed and discredited information to her handlers in Washington DC about police killings. INDECOM was born with much input from (FAST) and (JFJ) , however there were many more anti-police groups with significant power which pushed for a law which would basically shackle the police once and for all. The Norman Manley Law School and the Island’s Bar Association were instrumental in having a law passed which would effectively send crime sky-rocketing . The Administration did not bother to consult or consider the Police , Military or the Corrections Department before formulating and passing the law. INDECOM was born and Carolyn Gomes was awarded a National honor. It did not take long for the Nation’s criminals to figure out that the Police were now a paper tiger.
Gomes has since stepped down after much scrutiny by the Government of the Group’s financial records
and conduct. The alliance between (jfj) and (indecom) was well known, at least to this writer. This pissed off police officers who
Bruce Golding
demanded that Terrence Williams the head of (indecom) be fired after he attended an anti-police press conference with (jfj). The Government did not acquiesce to the Police’s demand but the well of goodwill was already poisoned between the police and the oversight agency. The Commissioner of (indecom) wanted and demanded more and more power to go after Police, this led to a battle with the office of the Director of Public Prosecution. Williams claimed that the DPP was not doing enough to prosecute police transgressions. Never mind that Williams had the option to grandstand but the DPP is obligated to present tangible evidence to a court of law or face unlawful prosecution backlash. It’s important to note that the (DPP) has the power to charge police officers with a crime to quell public outcry even without the requisite evidence necessary to convict. Literally every police shooting in Jamaica generates outcry from some quarter or another.
The tug-o-war ended up before Parliament with the DPP supported by the Police calling for oversight of (indecom) . Friends of (indecom) are enemies of the police and they did not abandon Williams as he pushed for more power to persecute police while notably wanting to have no oversight of (indecom). Essentially Williams wanted to head a super Agency voted into office by no one, but with vast unchecked powers.
Killings continue unabated ,
Citizens’ Action for Principles and Integrity (CAPI) says any oversight body for the Independent Commission of Investigations (Indecom), will render it impotent. A joint-select committee of parliament examining the Indecom Act has proposed an oversight entity for the investigative and prosecutorial body. Indecom was set up as an independent body tasked to investigate misconduct by members of the police force. Co-Convenor of CAPI Dennis Meadows argues that Indecom, as a commission of Parliament, already has parliamentary oversight in addition to judicial scrutiny with its financed and operations falling within the ambit of the Auditor General and the Contractor General. respectively. National Security Minister Peter Bunting has stated that there was a danger in concentrating as much power as
As a result of this reckless piece of poorly thought out legislation which placates criminal supporters citizens and police officers alike are being killed with no end in sight.
the act has done in the hands of the Commissioner of Indecom. At the time Human rights lobby group, Jamaicans for Justice said it was researching the proposal that the Independent Commission of Investigations (Indecom) should have an internal oversight. This latest proposal from parliamentarians follows earlier objections to Indecom having an external oversight. In a statement the JFJ says it continues to engage in robust advocacy at the policy level to protect and promote the human rights of all persons in Jamaica. Central to that advocacy has been the issue of police oversight. To this end, JFJ submitted its comments on the proposal for oversight of Indecom, to the joint-select committee of parliament reviewing the Indecom Act. The JFJ says its recent submission addresses the issue of external oversight of Indecom, as has been suggested by some parties. The lobby group says such additional external oversight of Indecom would be inappropriate and damaging to Indecom’s independence, potentially reversing the positive gains that have been made.
In the end the Joint select Committee of Parliament decided that more oversight was necessary as we reported here and correctly so. At the time the decision was made the sole Jamaica Labor Party Member of the committee in attendance Delroy Chuck an anti-police lawyer voted not to have oversight of (indecom). In summary (indecom) was created by the Labor Party . Dennis Meadows a JLP Senator and head of (Capi) wanted no oversight of (indecom). Delroy Chuck another JLP Senator voted for no oversight of (indecom). We have written about other Labor party aspirants here who have demosntrably shown a disdain for police officers and the rule of law. We need to know how many more members of the Labor Party wants unfettered powers for an oversight agency which is not required to face Jamaica’s criminals. As a commentator I have been strident against the PNP Administration for what I perceive to be incompetence, corruption, and a host of other malfeasance. In the interest of fairness however it is important to lay blame for the Island crime situation squarely where it belongs, on both political parties.
There are a lot of problems in Africa, exponentially more than may be found in any other part of the world. Extreme Poverty. Dangerous Diseases. Horrible Droughts. Horrendous Wars. Massive Corruption. Extreme Hunger. The list of problems and the extreme nature of each calamity causes us to turn the page or quickly scroll up or down so we don’t have to face the stark imagery. We hide from the imagery not because we are uncaring, we do so because sometimes the problems seem too large too momentous and so we feel helpless. We tell ourselves there is nothing we can do so why torture ourselves.
walter-palmer-and-cecil-the-lion
So with all of the problems plaguing the Continent of Africa why the outrage about the death of Cecil the Lion? Why has the death of a single Lion sparked such outrage across the Globe? According to the New York Times ‚Zimbabwe’s environment minister called Friday for the extradition of the American dentist who killed Cecil, a 13-year-old lion.
The minister, Oppah Muchinguri, said the dentist, Dr. Walter J. Palmer, a hunter from Minnesota, had broken Zimbabwe’s laws. At a news conference in Harare, the Zimbabwean capital, Ms. Muchinguri said that she understood the process was underway to have Dr. Palmer extradited from the United States and that the “foreign poacher” needed to be held accountable for his actions. “Unfortunately, it was too late to apprehend the foreign poacher, as he had already absconded to his country of origin,” she was quoted as saying by The Associated Press. “We are appealing to the responsible authorities for his extradition to Zimbabwe.”. Dr. Palmer a 55-year-old Minnesota Dentist and big game hunter said he trusted his Two Zimbabwean guides and that he acted on their advice before shooting the prized Lion which is a tourist attraction in the African country. Both Men have been arrested and are facing criminal charges in relation to the incident. Palmer allegedly paid $55,000 to hunt the lion. (According to NBC News, the guides, Theo Bronkhorst and Honest Ndlovu, could also face poaching charges and, if found guilty, 10 years in jail.)
Dr. Palmer has issued a statement as a result of the firestorm which has developed over his killing of the prized 13 ‑year-old Cecil . In his statement Palmer said “Again, I deeply regret that my pursuit of an activity I love and practice responsibly and legally resulted in the taking of this lion,” Dr. Palmer concluded to his patients. “That was never my intention.” In the meantime Dr.Palmer has stayed out of sight of US Authorities amidst the calls for his extradition to answer to charges in Zimbabwe. The United States has a treaty with Zimbabwe under which someone charged with an offense punishable by a sentence of at least a year in both countries can be extradited. On Friday, a Justice Department spokesman said the agency did not comment on extradition requests from foreign governments. In the meantime a petiton on the White House website has collected over 200,000 signatures calling for Dr Palmer’s extradition to Zimbabwe to face charges. The White house maintains it will react to any petition which collects over 100,000 signatures.
In the meantime there is a side of the American Media which may be fuelling International outrage. Many have been saying that under no circumstance should Palmer be extradited to face charges. They cite a litany of issues including allegations of Human Rights abuse by Zimbabwe and President Mugabe. This outrages many observers across the world as it outrages this writer. A treaty is a treaty . The United States has a duty to honor treaties it is signatory to . Therefore there should be no discussion about whether or not Dr. Walter Palmer should be extradited to Zimbabwe to face charges . The United States would expect no less were the situation reversed. As a member of the International community and one that takes onto itself the role of lecturing others about obeying International laws and treaties it is important that the United States practice what it preaches and do what is right. It cannot be that there are two sets of rules , one for the rest of the world and another for the United States.
I recall in 2010 the United States adamantly asked that Christopher Coke be extradited to face charges in the US for crimes many argued were committed in Jamaica. In the end Christopher Dudus Coke was extradited, tried ‚and convicted he is presently serving a lengthy sentence in a Federal prison. Before all of that however the process saw massive street unrest and violence between supporters of Coke and Police. Police Stations were torched , members of the security forces were eventually killed. A massive Military/Police incursion into Tivoli Gardens annexed the community to the rest of the country, but not before an estimated 73 people lost their lives.
The United States just concluded serious negotiations as part of the so-called P5 and 1 surrounding the issue of Iran’s nuclear program. The (P5) Permanent 5 , includes the United States, Russia , France, England and China, Iran being the one(1). The negotiations centered on what the United States and it’s allies including Israel says is Iran’s pursuit of Nuclear weapons contrary to International nuclear non-proliferation treaties. Iran has steadfastly insisted that it’s Nuclear program is for domestic peaceful purposes only. Notwithstanding the very same sector of the population is fighting to kill the deal the (P5) reached with Iran without offering an alternative deal. It is important to note that in the absence of a deal the Iranians would have no restraints on it’s nuclear program and may simply go ahead and produce nuclear bombs. It is also important to note that what the political Right and the bleeding heart Liberals who blindly follow Israel really want is war with Iran.
This brings us full circle to the killing of Cecil. There are those in America who want to dictate to the rest of the world how they should act , yet they believe the same rules ought not apply to them. Thankfully that is not a Universal view. Many conscientious Americans want Dr. Walter Palmer extradited to face charges and so he should . This writer share that belief.…
As an un-apologetic crusader against the (indecom) Act as configured, I am pleased to see that the Joint Select Committee of Parliament has come to it’s senses at least in this case and decided to add oversight to (indecom). Form the inception of (indecom) I argued stridently that the (JCF) should have oversight, however I believed then and still do today that at present what obtains is an adversarial confrontational elitists approach being employed by the neophyte agency which is headed by Terrence Williams now in his second five year term. Williams is a power hungry narcissist who has an over inflated ego and a rapacious desire for more and more unfettered power.
Williams from the get go created an adversarial environment between his office and the entire Jamaica Constabulary Force which poisoned any well of goodwill and coöperation which could potentially have existed, which by the way would be beneficial to him the JCF and the country. Doing his job well and maintaining respectful coöperation with the JCF are not mutually exclusive goals. That was not what Williams wanted. Williams was proud to make sure certain sections of the society knew that he was adversarial with the Police when he shared a stage with the group Jamaicans for Justice and its then head Carolyn Gomes an activist who deliberately created much enmity, and spread much lies and mis-information about excessive police behavior.
This is not to say that the police was not guilty of some of the transgressions members were accused of committing. Notwithstanding because of the advocacy and lobbying effort of the group it was outside the realm of whats appropriate for Williams to share the stage with them at the time. The police then called on the Government to fire Williams , needless to say the Government did not acquiesce to those demands . I don’t believe the Police expected the Government to do anything they asked for.
Most strikingly Williams has rapaciously pursed more and more power arguing he needed Prosecutorial powers to go after members of the Police Department, the Military and Corrections Departments. In an illuminating stroke of irony Terrence Williams simultaneously opposed any oversight of his (indecom).. Williams did not make enemies of just the Police , Military and Corrections, he picked fights with the nation’s Director of Public Prosecution (DPP) Paula Llewelyn. Of course in Jamaica no one wants to share power so this did not sit well with the (DPP). The matter came up for review in Parliament. The idea of another oversight level for the commission was introduced by Minister of National Security, Peter Bunting and Minister of Justice, Senator Mark Golding within the committee. However it was theDPP who suggested it to Parliament, following a row with (indecom) boss, Terrence Williams, over her handling of the case involving the controversial killing of aspiring DJ Robert “Kentucky Kid” in 2009 by the police.. Williams does not believe in the Prosecutorial process in place to adequately weigh and present evidence. What he wants is carte-blancheto go after officers with unchecked powers to persecute, not prosecute.
Many members of the JSC did not want to check the unfettered powers of (indecom) and it’s Napoleonic leader, mostly out of fear for the howls of condemnation which is sure to ensue from the criminal rights fraternity particularly in the Bar Association and the Norman Manley Law school at the Mona Campus UWI. Notwithstanding after Bunting read a letter addressed to Golding outlining his views on the matter the committee had an about face. In his letter Bunting said »>.
With very little oversight from Parliament, Commissioner Williams, and possibly his team at INDECOM, “decides administrative, investigate and prosecutorial issues with no operational review”. “The quality and fairness of these decisions are critical to maintaining both the confidence of the public, as well as the trust of the security forces,” Bunting said. “Importantly, if members of the security forces conclude that engaging armed violent criminals is a ‘no win’ exercise for them, then we run the risk of facilitating criminal impunity with obvious adverse consequences to the society”.
I have been making the very same arguments in this medium. I am extremely pleased to see that finally common sense has prevailed in this matter. Too many people die when police refrain from going after criminals. I have repeatedly asked do we all have a desire to see Jamaica with less crime? The people who support (indecom’s)power grab are benefiting greatly and have always benefited from crime in the past. They are the Nation’s criminal lawyers , many of whom double as legislators. Therein lies the problem.
I read about the murders rapes , shootings and other felonies being committed in Jamaica daily. I also read and watch videos of gruesome crimes being committed against women and even defenseless innocent babies. I do so with trepidation and fear. Fear for family and friends who live in Jamaica. I also fear for the lives of the good police officers who place their lives on the line daily believing they can make a difference on an Island where the people largely do not understand the benefits good law-enforcement bring to their lives and a Government which is quite content to keep them ignorant. Crime is a phenomenon which feeds on acquiescence and opportunity. That means crime metastasize when the people are ambivalent to it and when the people actually create opportunities for it to occur,.
It will be difficult to make a case that Jamaica is not ambivalent and in many ways engage in creating the environment for crime to flourish both by omission and commission. Our Police are woefully incapable of making a dent in crime as a result and are in many cases now simply engaged in ensuring their own survival. Despite the continued escalation in the number of serious crimes being committed on the Island the Administration seem more concerned with erecting barriers which would prevent the Police from having success than actually declaring war on organized crime. Some argue the political Directorate is actively engaged in serious corruption and other criminal acts. The Police Department suffer greatly from Political interference in their ability to do their jobs. Interference comes in the form of transfers, lack of promotion and may even mean much more serious consequences if the wrong person is prosecuted even when they commit heinous crimes. This is not lost on the criminal underworld which exploit every opening it gets to increase it’s assault on law abiding Jamaicans.
Portia Simpson Miller
There is much to-do now about (indecom) , the agency was created by the former Jamaica Labor Party Administration after what many saw as out of control police abuse and corruption. The new Agency has responsibility to police the Military, the Police and Corrections Departments. On the face of it no one can deny the need for police oversight in light of recent occurrences not just in Jamaica but in the United States of Americas well. Many on the sidelines with axes to grind and personal agendas naïvely’ and in many case ignorantly argue that if police officers are not breaking the laws they have nothing to fear from aggressive oversight.
Those statements lack a fundamental understanding of the challenges Police officers face in executing their duties. When we talk about policing in Jamaica those challenges are multiplied exponentially. Oversight cannot be adversarial and or confrontational with policing. Effective oversight works cohesively with police in order to remove corruption . It cannot be a witch-hunt aimed at making criminals out of people who act in good faith in the lawful execution of their mandates and are forced to make life and death decisions in split second scenarios. One cannot fully understand those nuances unless one has donned a police uniform and faced the circumstances officers face. Even the most ardent critics of police in many developed countries adjust their positions when placed in simulated situations in which they have to make split second decisions. That is the reason police are given such wide latitude to do their jobs in developed countries. That is not to say Police are justified in expanding those latitudes and interpretations of right and wrong. That is where properly focused intelligent oversight comes in. Police oversight cannot be conducted with a view to indicting or imprisoning officers, the police is not the enemy. Officers go out to do good. It cannot be done because someone wants to be seen. It cannot be done so one can build a reputation or a resume as is the current situation in Jamaica.
Andrew Holness
At present (indecom) is not an effective oversight agency. As presently configured and authorized it is a confrontational (pseudo-rights agency) not far removed from the phalanx of other so-called rights agencies operating on the Island. Throwing a white face into the mix does not legitimize (indecom), it actually prove the opposite. Insofar as foreign governments and Departments are concerned if they wanted Jamaica to progress they would be offering aid in training, equipment, technical know-how and other operational upgrades to the JCF not offering money to aid and comfort (indecom). Every country which offers money or other aid to (indecom) have strong police agencies which they do not allow any agency or person to conflict with.
As I have reported from speaking to officers on the ground there is really no effective investigations from the Island’s detectives. Many would have you believe Jamaican officers and by extension our detectives are sub-standard or in some way inferior to their counterparts in other countries. The fact is that the evidence points in the opposite direction. Time after time whenever members of the JCF compete or participate in training courses with their contemporaries from other countries, including the developed world our officers perform in exemplary fashion , in many instances outshining those officers.
Presently there are ambiguities between the police and (indecom) as to who has control of certain crime scenes. How does an oversight agency have control of a scene of crime is beyond comprehension. The challenge for Jamaica is not an unavailability of talent and commitment . Jamaicans need to reorient it’s views on the rule of law and make a decision whether it wants to be similar to a sub-Saharan fiefdom controlled by warlords or a progressive 21st century Island positioned for growth and development. Only the people can decide that. If their actions of the past are anything to go by I do not hold out much hope for the foreseeable future.
There is much speculation regarding the death of (JCF) Corporal Tyrone Thompson, thus far media reports suggest suicide. Initial reports suggest the officer was found lying dead in bed by his twin brother also a police officer of the same rank clutching a weapon with a single gunshot wound to the head. Media leaks also suggest he had asked for a transfer to another station and that he was having personal and relationship problems. As far as we know there is no official cause of death from Police Investigators. However there is a picture of what appears to be the deceased on social media which begs the question, who made that photograph available ? Was it the Police and if so why? If it wasn’t the Police who else have had access to the scene?
Police corporal Tyrone Thompson
As we await a cause of death we are reminded that the death of corporal Thompson is just another in a series of three deaths of police officers in a matter of days. Constables Curtis Lewis and Crystal Johnson both lost their lives in the line of duty a few days before Corporal Thompson. Despite my personal objection to the release of the photograph of Corporal Thomas (if not a fake) I too have some observations which contradicts the notion that his death was a suicide. Lets not forget that there still is no official word from the police. In the meantime the rumor mill keep churning .
The photograph which appears on social media is stirring a massive debate regarding whether the cause of death could possibly be suicide. Many officers past and present have offered up theories why they believe he could not have shot himself. Points of contention are varied and many . My observations are simple. ♦ The position of his arm with the weapon laying loosely in his right arm appear to have been placed in his hand after he was killed. If he shot himself in the head it seem to me the weapon would have fallen from his hand closer to his head and not come back to where his hand was to rest comfortably in his palm. ♦ His body was in a fetal position which suggest he was sleeping . If he was sleeping that is inconsistent with suicide. ♦From all appearance he was shot while sleeping. ♦ I would say he never knew what hit him. All of this is speculation in the absence of an official cause of death from the Police. Now that these opinions are in the public domain, hopefully the police will not come out with a suicide cause of death which would make them look really silly and do a tremendous dis-service to the family of this fallen officer.
Out of respect for corporal Thompson’s family we decided not to not to post the picture of his body.
As the debate rages about the powers of the Independent Commission of Investigations (INDECOM), to arrest and prosecute members of the police force, a Joint Select Committee of Parliament on Thursday, continued to examine whether the body should be given more power to operate and widen its remit.
INDECOM has been pressing the government to amend sections of the act under which it operates. The changes, being sought by Terrence Williams, INDECOM’s Commissioner, are geared at giving the body prosecutorial powers similar to that enjoyed by the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). However,the police and the army have vehemently objected to the request saying it will undermine fairness and will be to the detriment of their members. In her presentation, Paula Llewellyn, DPP, said several critical issues must be considered before a decision can be made. “If the conflicts are not properly resolved and if there is not at the heart of the process collegiate consultation, what will happen is that the prosecution of a case investigated by INDECOM and the police or INDECOM alone or the police alone — which also touches and concerns INDECOM, will be undermined.” She said the situation is further compounded by a lack of clarity in who should take responsibility for a crime scene and other discrepancies under Section 33 of the INDECOM Act.
According to Sanchia-Gaye Burrell , Deputy DPP , as it stands the lack of clarity in the act gives allowances to creating a doubt about one’s innocence. “Defense counsel will always latch onto whatever it is that they believe will advance their clients case, now we will have to be placed in a position to have to clarify — why does JCF have some, why does INDCOME have some, who is investigating?” she said. The DPP also stated that INDECOM has to foster greater respect for the groups challenging its request. She suggested that if amendments are to be made, then provision should be put in place to mandate further consultation on the part of in INDECOM in prosecutorial matters. Story originated here: http://rjrnewsonline.com/local/joint-select-committee-debates-indecoms-power-to-prosecute
Jamaica has a past which include slavery and oppression much the same way Blacks have suffered and continue to suffer in the United States. The difference between our two systems is that for the most part the slave masters either died out or left Jamaica. In the United States they remained,. But back to Jamaica.
The slave-masters left but they left a group of people who believe in the idea of superiority based on certain characteristics they define. So we have a dichotomy which is the so-called upper-class and well.… everyone else. It’s kind of the same situation which was left in Rwanda after the Colonizing Germans and
Belgians left. The movie blood diamond was a unique window into what
Two sides of Jamaica
Belgium King Leopold did before leaving Rwanda . They created two groups between the people, the Hutus and the Tutsi from the very same people. This caused the people to continue to fight among themselves on manufactured difference, long after they had left. The Hutu-Tutsi strife stems from class warfare, with the Tutsis perceived to have greater wealth and social status (as well as favoring cattle ranching over what is seen as the lower-class farming of the Hutus). The Tutsis are thought to have originally come from Ethiopia, and arrived after the Hutu came from Chad. The Tutsis had a monarchy dating back to the 15th century; this was overthrown at the urging of Belgian colonizers in the early 1960s and the Hutu took power by force in Rwanda. In Burundi, however, a Hutu uprising failed and the Tutsis controlled the country. Jamaica’s so-called upper-class basically boasts some of the very same characteristics. Wealth and
Jamaican soldiers in Tivoli Gardens in 2010..
lighter skin color, the more contemporary characteristic is based on who manages to secure some sort of education and is able to use it to separate and differentiate themselves from everyone else. There has been a paradigm shift as it relates to color however. Though color has not been removed from the equation as a defining point-to-prove class, education and wealth-accumulation have leveled the playing field somewhat.
The Hutu and Tutsi speak the same Bantu tongues as well as French, and generally practice Christianity and many geneticists have been hard-pressed to find marked ethnic differences between the two, though the Tutsi have generally been noted to be taller. The Tutis are from Ethopia and the Hutu generally from Chad, both groups are Africans. Jamaicans of all stripes speak the same tongue.
Jamaicans uptown Kingston 6 and 8 delude themselves that a few social differences set
The two sides of Jamaica
them apart from their contemporaries in Kingston 12 and 13 . The crime situation on the Island is fueled partly because of anger on the part of those in Kingston 12 and 13 , pretty soon gated communities and security guards will not be enough. Despite more of its members now have undergraduate and graduate degrees than arguably any other police department in the world the upper caste in Jamaica still holds the Police officers of the JCF in contempt. In order to fully understand this one would have to understand the full history of the JCF and how it came into existence and the struggles it has faced as an entity for law and order, while having to cope with the country’s bourgeois’. Read more here: The Jamaica Constabulary Force
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.