What Policing Is Becoming…

Having spent the bet­ter part of a decade research­ing, writ­ing and talk­ing about the rule of law, race, and how law enforce­ment has affect­ed peo­ple’s lives through the years, I am dis­gust­ed to see the state of law enforce­ment today.
The hue and cry against those who enforce our laws are cer­tain­ly not just in Jamaica as some would like to have you believe. In the great big United States, with its thou­sands of police depart­ments, it is far worse. As a result, every police actions as it relates to peo­ple of col­or and African-Americans, in par­tic­u­lar, has come under immense scruti­ny because of the actions of police offi­cers.
In an age when images and video record­ings of police-civil­ian inter­ac­tions are broad­cast­ed viral­ly across the inter­net, it appears that police offi­cers have become far more bru­tal and uncar­ing about the peo­ple they are sworn to pro­tect.
Whether this is so or not, is not for me to say. The fact that images and live videos are so eas­i­ly avail­able for our view­ing may have some­thing to do with that.
What is patent­ly clear though is that the images are not pretty.

The United States, is a coun­try con­stant­ly embroiled in racial ani­mos­i­ty and strife. It is not always easy to dif­fer­en­ti­ate between good polic­ing and race-based polic­ing when white offices are involved with black sus­pects.
In Jamaica, the com­mon refrain by those who break the laws is that police arrest them because they are poor. Never mind that the offi­cers are gen­er­al­ly just as poor as they are, or poor­er.
Stopping a man in Cherry Gardens with a bag con­tain­ing imple­ments of house­break­ing, night or day, elic­its that same response.
As a con­se­quence, I am con­strained against my gut instincts, when inci­dents of alleged abuse sur­faces, involv­ing black cit­i­zens and white police offi­cers.
Nevertheless, the key ques­tion I gen­er­al­ly ask myself in thse instances is, ‘would the offi­cer black, white Latino or oth­er­wise have act­ed the way he/​she did were the sus­pects white”?
I am also mind­ful of the fact that the abil­i­ty to pro­file is a vital tool police offi­cers have in their toolk­it to help them make polic­ing deci­sions.
Done well, done right, that deduc­tive rea­son­ing serves our com­mu­ni­ties very well.
It becomes a prob­lem when rogue ele­ments in law enforce­ment use it to live out their racist bias­es in America.
It becomes a prob­lem when bru­tal cops use it to exact pun­ish­ment on those they deem pow­er­less in Jamaica.

The rule of law if applied fair­ly and pro­por­tion­ate­ly is the best method we have to main­tain demo­c­ra­t­ic soci­eties. When the laws are applied fair­ly, just­ly, equi­tably and pro­por­tion­ate­ly, in a man­ner in which all feel equal under the laws, it makes for bet­ter soci­eties and a pros­per­ous future for all.
When the poor is made to feel less than in the eyes of the law, or oth­ers are made to feel the same way because of their race, sex­u­al orientation,religion, or oth­er dis­tin­guish­able char­ac­ter­is­tic soci­eties are less peace­ful, less pros­per­ous.
As a con­se­quence the rule of law is heav­i­ly depen­dent of those who enforce our laws to be just and fair.
Unfortunately those who enforce our nation’s laws are weak humans pre­dis­posed to the weak­ness­es of human bias­es.
The fol­low­ing is one such sto­ry from our friends at CNN​.com.

Ex-deputy accused of planting drugs on Florida drivers is arrested

Zachary Wester faces racketeering, fabricating evidence, false imprisonment and other charges.
Zachary Wester faces rack­e­teer­ing, fab­ri­cat­ing evi­dence, false impris­on­ment and oth­er charges. 

(CNN)Florida author­i­ties have arrest­ed a for­mer Jackson County deputy accused of mak­ing false arrests after plant­i­ng drugs on dri­vers, police said in a statement.The alle­ga­tions have prompt­ed pros­e­cu­tors to drop charges in scores of cases.Zachary Wester, 26, was tak­en into cus­tody at his Crawfordville home, about 20 miles south of Tallahassee, on Wednesday, accord­ing to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. He is being held in Wakulla County Jail with­out bail, the FDLE said.He stands charged with felony counts of rack­e­teer­ing, offi­cial mis­con­duct, fab­ri­cat­ing evi­dence, pos­ses­sion of a con­trolled sub­stance and false impris­on­ment. He also faces mis­de­meanor charges of per­jury, pos­ses­sion of a con­trolled sub­stance and pos­ses­sion of drug para­pher­na­lia, the FDLE said​.At least 11 peo­ple are suing Wester in fed­er­al court for alleged civ­il rights vio­la­tions as well.

100+ cases tossed out

At the request of the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office, Wester’s for­mer employ­er, the FDLE began inves­ti­gat­ing the deputy in August after body­cam video from a February 2018 arrest appeared to show Wester plant­i­ng metham­phet­a­mine in Teresa Odom’s pick­up truck dur­ing a traf­fic stop, FDLE spokesman Jeremy Burns told CNN in September​.At the time, the FDLE was review­ing 254 of Wester’s cas­es, pros­e­cu­tors said.“The inves­ti­ga­tion shows Wester rou­tine­ly pulled over cit­i­zens for alleged minor traf­fic infrac­tions, plant­ed drugs inside their vehi­cles and arrest­ed them on fab­ri­cat­ed drug charges,” the FDLE said in its Wednesday news release, adding that it had reviewed more than 21 hours of footage in its investigation.

Video shows Baltimore cop plant evidence, lawyer says

It added, “Wester cir­cum­vent­ed JCSO’s body cam­era pol­i­cy and tai­lored his record­ings to con­ceal his crim­i­nal activity.“Wester’s attor­ney did not imme­di­ate­ly return a phone call seek­ing comment.State Attorney Glenn Hess’ office said in September 2018 that 119 cas­es had been dropped and about 10 peo­ple had been released from prison. CNN could not imme­di­ate­ly reach Hess on Wednesday, but local media reports indi­cate the probe has widened since then.Wester was fired September 10. It was not imme­di­ate­ly clear how long Wester had been with the depart­ment, but the Tallahassee Democrat report­ed he resigned from the Liberty County Sheriff’s Office in May 2016 and lat­er took the job in Jackson County.

It damned sure ain’t mine’

Bodycam video from Odom’s February 2018 arrest in Cottondale shows Wester approach the car in a friend­ly man­ner and explain to the woman that her brake lights are malfunctioning.He leaves with her license, and as he returns to her vehi­cle he jokes that his hip almost gave out. Odom tells him her moth­er is in the hos­pi­tal and she’s expect­ing a call from a doc­tor. Wester tells her that a drug dog is on its way, but Odom says she has noth­ing in the car and gives him con­sent to search it.Wester appears to hold some­thing in his left hand as he dons black gloves before the search. His hand moves out of the frame for a few sec­onds and returns emp­ty. He fin­ish­es putting on the gloves and com­mences with the search.

Bodycam video appears to show Wester planting drugs in Odom's car last year.

Bodycam video appears to show Wester plant­i­ng drugs in Odom’s car last year.After “find­ing” a bag of white pow­der in her truck, he places it on the dri­ver seat but does­n’t alert two oth­er deputies on the scene. Instead, he moves it around, first plac­ing it on a spoon and then mov­ing it to the pas­sen­ger seat. All the while, he con­tin­ues the chum­my ban­ter with Odom.After search­ing the pas­sen­ger side of her vehi­cle, where he had just placed the bag­gie, he returns to Odom and anoth­er deputy with the spoon and pow­der. Odom says the spoon is for her yogurt but seems sur­prised by the bag of powder.“That is not mine. No, sir. No, sir,” she says.After the pow­der tests pos­i­tive for metham­phet­a­mine, Wester tells Odom she’s under arrest as she speaks on the phone with a relative.“He says it tests pos­i­tive for amphet­a­mine, so I guess I’m going to go to jail,” Odom tells the per­son on the phone. “It damned sure ain’t mine.”

Case remains open

Three fed­er­al law­suits have been filed against Wester. Eleven peo­ple arrest­ed by him claim the ex-deputy framed them, plant­i­ng some com­bi­na­tion of mar­i­jua­na, metham­phet­a­mine, pre­scrip­tion pills or drug para­pher­na­lia, includ­ing syringes and scales, in their vehi­cles after pulling them over for minor infrac­tions. Two law­suits were filed in December, and anoth­er was filed in May​.In the most recent­ly filed case, Lora Penn, one of nine plain­tiffs, says she was a pas­sen­ger in a vehi­cle pulled over June 7, 2018. During the stop, she alleged, Wester placed metham­phet­a­mine and a hypo­der­mic nee­dle in her purse.Penn was charged with drug and para­pher­na­lia pos­ses­sion and spent 12 days in jail before “her moth­er post­ed bond exhaust­ing her mea­ger finan­cial resources. Penn’s moth­er was there­after unable to afford med­ical care and died due to lack of such care,” the fed­er­al law­suit says.The FDLE, whose inves­ti­ga­tors have already logged 1,400 hours on the crim­i­nal case against Wester, says the probe remains open and encour­ages any­one with infor­ma­tion to come forward.“There is no ques­tion that Wester’s crimes were delib­er­ate and that his actions put inno­cent peo­ple in jail,” said Chris Williams, the FDLE’s assis­tant spe­cial agent in charge of the Pensacola office.Prior to his time with the Jackson County Sheriff’s Office, Wester worked in Liberty County. Jack Campbell, the state attor­ney there, told CNN affil­i­ate WCTV in May that inves­ti­ga­tors were in the process of “resolv­ing” some cas­es involv­ing the for­mer law­man. He would not elab­o­rate on how many cas­es, the sta­tion reported.The sta­tion has pre­vi­ous­ly report­ed Campbell was review­ing 26 cases.

CNN’s Amir Vera, Marlena Baldacci and Amanda Watts con­tributed to this report.