The co-founder of the Black Lives Matter movement talked to The Nation about her initiative to engage skeptics and build political power among black communities.
In 2015, I profiled activist and organizer Alicia Garza as part of Glamour’s “Women of the Year” issue. Garza, along with Patrisse Cullors and Opal Tometi, is credited with coining the phrase #BlackLivesMatter, popularizing the hashtag and for its quick ascendance into a nationally recognized movement against police brutality and violence. Profiling Garza in Glamour felt like a big deal — it solidified her, and Black Lives Matter, as having penetrated the consciousness of mainstream America.
Since then, Black Lives Matter has gone from a rallying cry to an organization with more than twenty chapters, which is that is part of a racial-justice coalition of over 50 other organizations. A mission statement was drawn up, demands were made.
But after the election of Donald Trump, which many in the movement see as a nationalist backlash to the core principles Black Lives Matter has brought into focus, we began to see a drop-off in the media coverage of protests and actions. But perhaps that’s not the best measure of the movement. “Protest is best used when it’s part of a strategy that involves escalating tactics that build pressure on targets,” Garza told me. Aware of in the political environment we’ve now found ourselves in, Garza, who is still one of the most visible organizers of the Black Lives Matter movement, recently launched the Black Futures Lab, a project that will be devoted to engaging in the electoral process without neglecting deeper organizing. “Our mission to engage Black voters year-round; our commitment to using our political strength to stop corporate influences from creeping into progressive policies; and our plan to combine technology and traditional organizing methods to reach Black people anywhere and everywhere we are,” its website explains. Garza’s recent efforts have been touted by Senator Kamala Harris and television giant Shonda Rhimes. Read more here: https://www.thenation.com/article/black-americans-face-impossible-choices-at-election-time-alicia-garza-wants-to-change-that/
We knew the INDECOM act was flawed, we knew it’s execution was flawed and we said so. Today this writer was vindicated in the Jamaican high court. We have consistently maintained that though oversight of our law enforcement agencies is critical there has to be a balance in its applications as we must be deferential to the challenges law enforcement officers face.
It is not a blank check as some detractors are wont to accuse because they are unable to defend their point of view, but rather an understanding that unless we have first-hand knowledge of an issue we must give credence to the views of those who do. It is against that backdrop that I personally opposed the INDECOM bill even before it became law and have written dozens of articles explaining in depth why it would create a chill to law enforcement and would do precious little in a positive way over and above what the other seven oversight agencies were already doing.
For eight years (8) I argued that this law is driving crime, for eight years INDECOM argued crime was high before it’s creation. For eight years INDECOM crowed that police fatal shootings have gone down because of its vigilance. For eight years I have argued that police fatal shootings have gone down not because criminals are any less lethal but because police officers are standing down. For eight years I have taken the abuse of the criminal rights fraternity in the country for daring to call for the repeal of the INDECOM act. Neither political party in Government has done anything to revisit the law despite the glaring inconsistencies in it and their own observations that it is indeed flawed.
We are proud of the many long hours of hard work and research we have put into bringing awareness to the Jamaican public and people across the Globe about what is happening in Jamaica. We are proud that in the face of a near blanket smear campaign against the police officers who risk their lives daily to create a modicum of peace and safety to the indoctrinated anti-police violence we decided to speak truth to power. With the juxtaposition of the authorities violation of members right to free speech rights which effectively sanctions them for speaking out against the injustice meted out to them any advocacy on their behalf is incredibly valuable to their morale.
It is with that thought in mind that this medium was born in 2011. (1)Out of a sense of helplessness, I felt for the nations police officers who do so much under horrible working conditions, with less than appropriate tools of the trade and with their hands tied behind their backs. (2) Out of an understanding that the vast majority of the uneducated people in our country deserve a life, a life free from crime and terror. Out of an understanding that it is those same people who surrender their children to become police officers. Out of an understanding that without the rule of law we don’t have a country. Out of an understanding that despite its flaws (which we have to fix) it is the police who are called when we need help.
It is that sense of duty why I made this personal call to arms so that those of us who walked away do not simply sit on the sidelines because we may be doing better with our lives. We owe a debt of gratitude to that beautiful little country we all love so very much.
Add your name whether you are a former Police officer or not. Show support for the betterment of our Country of birth Jamaica. Let us make a stand against corruption and crime once and for all. It is through our numbers that we will bring change. As we have seen the Government of both Political parties have not done enough Legislatively or through other means of support to build a modern, effective Police Department. Maybe most importantly it hasn’t created the environment in which police officers may operate without the threat of imminent death simply for doing what they are sworn to do. Register your decision to stand for change whether you wholeheartedly support the JCF or not. This is not the forum for gripes about the police. We cannot have a civilized society without police officers and the rule of law. Let us start on that premise. We need your support.
That has been our clarion call before the INDECOM act was passed into law on April 15, 2010, it is our clarion call today, almost eight years later, even as the Court of Appeal has spoken quite loudly that INDECOM cannot have carte blanch to do as it pleases. Th road to a better Jamaica is a long and arduous one, our advocacy for fairness and the rule of law will intensify so that we can enjoy the promise of a country in which all Jamaicans have an equal say and equal protection under the laws so that endemic crime and violence will be a thing of the past.
The court of appeals has just made an earth-shattering ruling today. In a 2 – 1 decision, the court ruled that INDECOM has no power of arrest and as such has no power to arrest and charge any member of the JCF. We will say more after we have seen the decision.
UPDATETOTHISSTORY> This publication wishes to congratulate DSP Dyer who stood up to a bully and was not swayed in the face of what this publication and this writer has long maintained was the action of a rogue commission and a narcissistic media hogging commissioner whose sole goal it seems is to solidify power in order to use it against the nation’s security forces.
In 2014 Dyer was convicted for interfering with an INDECOM probe and fined $800,000.Dyer challenged the ruling and took the matter to the high court. We also wish to congratulate the Appeals court which interpreted the law as it is configured and made the appropriate ruling. The Dyer case emerged from an incident in which INDECOM went to the Central Village Police Station to confiscate the weapons involved in a shooting case involving the police.
DSP Dyer refused to hand over the weapons and was subsequently subpoenaed to appear in the Half Way Tree Resident Magistrate Court where he was fined the outrageous sum. Fortunately, DSP Dyer was not cowed by that ruling and decided that the courts are there for all Jamaicans, not just a few. This ruling by the high court quashes Dyer’s conviction and sends an earth-shattering message to INDECOM that tyranny will not suffice.
The agency has a responsibility to impartially investigate and turn over it’s findings to the duly constituted office of the Director of Public Prosecution. We cannot have a rogue agency of Government going off on its own sowing discord in the law enforcement community as hundreds of Jamaicans are murdered each month.
This ruling is not a victory for rogue cops, it is balanced ruling for good cops who want to do their jobs. Advocacy works. My regards to my young intellectual friend who just told me this ruling paves the way for the newly appointed Commissioner of Police Major General Anthony Anderson to be successful. An awesome point of view in light of the murder rate.
I once again call on this Government to repeal this onerous crime enhancement law now.
A new Police Post opened in Green Acres, Spanish Town St. Catherine on Thursday, March 15th. Whatever can be done to reduce response time by the police is always a good thing. In fact, I recently wrote that whoever the new commissioner of police is he/she should work hard to ensure that response time is cut exponentially.
People are consoled immensely when they have an idea that when they call the police the police is going to be there in record time. Citizens can experience no greater sense of terror than to be in trouble with no recourse or expectation of help coming from the police.
The new Police Post just opened in Green Acres, Spanish Town, St. Catherine on Thursday, March 15th.
And so with that in mind, it is a welcome sign to see a new facility erected which will potentially bring a certain degree of consolation to residents in and around the immediate area of Green Acres Spanish Town. At the risk of sounding hypercritical, I made peace with being deluged with condemnation from those who see this as a great achievement for the people in the area.
Should I worry about the potential blowback though, when the thing seems like it is actually a trailer? Ok so I am told it is actually a trailer with some paint and accouterments slapped onto it.
There are parts of the world where people are putting these containers to good use, including retrofitting them to house the homeless. Nothing wrong with that at all, in fact, I would be glad to have had one of those as my home as a young officer working in Jamaica based on the stipend we were given then.
Okay so they are able to make coffee, whats to complain about,? yippee…
Retrofitting these containers to house those who cannot afford to purchase a home makes a lot of sense, but does it make sense that we are asking our police officers to be caged in these death traps considering the high-velocity weapons in the hands of the gangsters?
I hate to be the guy who pricks the balloon, but people are asking why should the police settle for this death trap when one certain minister of Government’s cell phone bill was J$18.000,000?
The Former Darling Street Police Station, a concrete structure burned, officers shot.
Ok, I’m just the messenger I really only care about the welfare of the young men and women who are going to be risking life and limb in that cage. I have a certain respect for the parents who allow their children to enter the service of their country in the JCF, considering the lawlessness of the country and the lack of thanks, officers get for risking their lives working in dangerous and shitty conditions for a paltry stipend.
No shortage of dignitaries to memorialize this monumental accomplishment.[sic]So I ask about the safety of that death trap against existing precedent not out of some desire to be argumentative or anti-government as the JLP partisans will accuse me of being, never bothering to talk about the times when I criticize the PNP.
In the final analysis, we have to consider what we are doing here, what are we spending money on, regardless of the cost? Other nations build infrastructure which lasts for centuries, Jamaica build for today and so we will have to keep building into perpetuity.
Who remembered the Hannah Town police station?
This is another stop-gap investment in the police and law enforcement, at the expense of police officers lives as long as it seems that we are doing something politically. Like ZOSO and the State of Public Emergency are also stop-gap partisan measures designed to allay fear and anxiety.
HEREISWHERENONEOFTHISMAKESSENSE .……WELLTOME.
It all makes sense now, dictatorship maybe?
With the maintenance of law and order high on the agenda of the Government, a sum of $8.4 billion has been budgeted to bolster the capabilities of the Jamaica Defence Force (JDF).
This includes $1.77 billion for cybersecurity initiatives by the JDF; $1.36 billion to increase the mobility of the JDF; $2.45 billion to purchase helicopters to assist in search and rescue, casualty evacuation, medical evaluation and training; $1.32 billion to strengthen the capability of the JDF within Jamaica’s maritime zone; and $1.5 billion for the construction of new integrated training, accommodation, office and storage facilities.
Details of the project are outlined in the 2018⁄19 Estimates of Expenditure. The Estimates were recently tabled in the House of Representatives by Minister of Finance and the Public Service, Hon. Audley Shaw.(Source JIS)
Well, at least we are now up to speed and ready to take on North Korea, eat your heart out Kim Jong-un.
This is not the first time that I have spoken on this subject and so I will be as brief as possible even though I am not convinced I won’t have to do so again. (Two things really).
I wish I had a dollar for each time an officer of the JCF tells me, please Mr. Beckles continue to speak out on our behalf, no one else does. This really breaks my heart. “The gazetted ranks do not speak out for us and in many cases, they are used to persecute us” they lament. Shocking, yet they tell me, “we cannot wait to see what you have to say but we do not comment or share your articles because they will use that to penalize us”. I never hesitate to tell them that there are a lot of us ex-police officers who do worry about their concerns, their safety, and their welfare if no one else does. A great many of us are not just ex-cops who gather to drink rum and play dominoes. (nothing wrong with the latter really), it’s just not our thing.
Sure , I understand that law enforcement departments generally have rules governing media policy and admittedly officers have to be circumspect in what they do, including on websites and social media. Nevertheless, the police have had onerous restrictions placed on their right to free speech which clearly has constitutional implications not to mention the moral considerations.
I write facts. Facts which are not always palatable to Jamaica’s social elites. I write facts which are generally inconvenient to the political caste as well as the criminal fraternity. The lines between the latter two are sometimes very difficult to distinguish. It frightens me that our police officers would be bullied by their own Government to the point they are petrified to respond to an article they find liberating. This brings into question the authenticity of our so-called Democracy in real ways.
But the very same Government has tabled a bill and passed an INDECOM law which takes away their right to have a few days to gather their wits before giving a full written accounting of their actions in shootouts in cases in which they are traumatized and sometimes injured and seen their colleagues killed. Former Commissioner George Quallo spoke out about this detailing accounts he has seen with young officers emerging from shootouts shaking and crying from the enormity fo their encounter, yet the INDECOM law forces them to give statements even in their mentally traumatized state.
Commissioner George Quallo was forced out for not following the government’s orthodoxy, on this and on other issues concerning the welfare of his officers. Despite the detractors, this medium and this writer salutes Commissioner Quallo for not carrying water for the government.
Former Commissioner Quallo in the foreground.
The Police again had their rights impugned in the recently passed Zones of Special Operations law(ZOSO), in which the administration attached an amendment which criminalizes them for leaving the department without giving a six-month notice. The police is not a military force, officers should have no restrictions placed on their God-given right to leave whenever they want to, including without even submitting a resignation like I did in 91, I simply dropped everything and walked away.
(2) “SQUADDY”
One of the things which have been used pejoratively to bash Police officers in Jamaica over the years is the word “SQUADDY”. That assault was basically engineered by Carolyn Gomes the pediatric doctor turned human rights advocate.[sic] Carolyn Gomes was eventually exposed for pushing homosexual literature on under age Jamaican kids in Government care. Of course not before receiving the Order of Jamaica. Go figure.
The word squaddy continue to be tarred and feathered in pejorative terms as a kind of terminology which gives aid and comfort to dirty cops, some kind of code of silence if you will. The only problem is that Carolyn Gomes had no more idea about what squaddy meant to cops than I know how to treat a colicky baby. The one endearing term which police officers had to refer to their colleagues was too much for them to have and so they launched a campaign of demonization against it. The poor people’s children should not have anything, not even a term of endearment to their colleagues with whom they sacrifice together for their country. And so it is not outside the realm of possibility that some of the bottom-feeding social climbers who have invaded the police department and have been pushed to the top do not themselves understand es.prit de corps. They are not cops and never will be. The anti-police village lawyers who never served in anything but gossip groups were quick to gobble up the demagoguery, like a running back they grabbed it and ran with it.
Hamish Campbell and Terrence Williams
And now the nation’s chief demagogue, Terrence Williams has it and he is running with it.Every chance that Charlatan gets he speaks about the squaddy mentality in a way that belies the endearment police officers feel when we say “squaddy”. If only this ignorant narcissistic little media whore took the time to ask an officer what the word means to him or her he would not continue to embarrass himself the way he does whenever he opens his mouth to speak. The wall of silence he sees encapsulated in the word “squaddy” exist only in his twisted mind.
“SQUADDY”
Terrence Williams Commissioner of INDECOM
Although I have written about this on previous occasions, I will do so once again in the interest of clarity, or until this farcical liar stops. Military, police officers and other groups the world over develop special bonds of friendship and camaraderie. That bond of kindred spirit is evident in cadet corps, girls and boys scout troupes, cub scouts etc. It is evident in college fraternities something Carolyn Gomes and Terrence Williams should have been conversant of since they are both college educated. I guess they missed those campus activities as they were too busy making mischief to engage in positive campus activities.
Whether it’s cub scouts, girls/boys scouts college fraternities police departments or whatever, those bonds are the memories we carry in our hearts for the people whom we spent those times with. They form the ties which bind us into service and common cause. Those bonds provide networking for college graduates which ensures if one succeeds all succeed. They are the ties which bind police officers when we say “squaddy,“because we depend on one another not to leave our brothers on the battlefield when we are shot and lay there bleeding. We are not ashamed of it, we will never be ashamed of it ‚get used to it.
It is that kindred spirit which says we stand with you when no one else will. That spirit of camaraderie which celebrates and commemorates our colleagues who we depend on to protect our backs as we engage those who would destroy society.
This is something dear to us and we will never feel bad about it. We will never be told, neither will we ever abandon the es.prit de corps, that feeling of pride, fellowship, and common loyalty we feel and share. And so to the lying, selfish self-serving Saul of Tarsus otherwise called (Terrence Williams) I say try service to others. Try doing something other than self-promotion and self-aggrandizement. Try belonging to something bigger than yourself and your narrow self-interest and maybe, just maybe you will feel a little bit of the pride we feel when we say “SQUADDY”.
At the time Andrew Holness was running around talking about what ZOSO was going to do as it regards crime I countered that given any scenario in which a flood or military and police bodies are thrown into a small geographical area crime would inexorably decline. The downside to that strategy I argued is that that strategy was vastly unsustainable as that process would have to be a nationwide strategy for it to have the desired effect.
Since Jamaica does not have hundreds of thousands of soldiers and police officers that strategy was, therefore, a stop-gap measure which could only placate and pacify the area in which the strategy is applied.
The stop-gap strategy was nevertheless applied and to the delight and crowing of the political class, the area in which the ZOSO was instituted has predictably been pacified to the chagrin and detriment of other areas. The criminals operating in that area of St James simply packed up and moved their trade to other areas and continued plying their nefarious and dastardly trade.
It is on this particular point which I want to focus my readers. Some of who were a little bit offended as they chided me for not waiting to see whether the thing would work. As I respectfully said to many of you over the period before and since it’s creation, ZOSO could not have the desired results we all craved because it does nothing to remove from the equation the chief producers of violence.
The process of lowering crime and removing the threat of vicious violence and death from the equation requires a strategy which first and foremost recognizes that the country is in a state of undeclared civil war. I have tried to make this point ad nauseam over the years, our country must attend to the state of undeclared civil war she is in. I have written several articles pointing to that very fact.
Yesterday I talked about the phenomenal amounts of money the Nation waste each year through an act created in 2010 by the Parliament under the leadership of Bruce Golding the then Prime Minister. In the 2016/2017 budget, the Government allocated to INDECOM M$366.492, for the period 2017/2018, M$353.35. After a 22 year neglect of the police department by the previous PNP Administration, and a growing murder problem Bruce Golding had an opportunity to take steps to recreate the police department by infusing the necessary resources in retraining and equipping the police department.
Instead of recognizing the built-in political and legislative failings which resulted in the failings of the police, Golding in collusion with the PNP, created INDECOM not just to appease the huge anti-police growth industry which had developed in the country but also their foreign handlers who dole out huge sums of money in support of INDECOM as opposed to assisting the principal law enforcement agency. In fact, for the same reporting periods, 2016/2017 M$230.616 and 2017/2018 M$202.476 of INDECOM’s budget came from overseas donors. Why?
The new JLP Administration in Kingston has demonstrated the very same disdain for law enforcement that the previous JLP administration of Golding did, this time on steroids. Hundreds of millions of dollars allocated to the 3’000 man defense force which is not likely to engage in a war anytime soon except in support of the police. The Defense force was given a lead role in the So-called ZOSO currently in effect in St James Parish. Selling the false sense of calm in that particular sector as an example of success when the Military is given the lead and that narrative being adopted and proffered by none other than INDECOM the JLP’s brainchild. If you are not willfully blind the circle of disrespect is pretty hard to miss.
The JCF with all of its shortcomings has been bookended by the two political parties the PNP which decidedly starved it of resources over a 22-year ‑period and the JLP which demonstrably have decided that its intent is to invest in the demise of policing on the Island.
ASANASIDE.…
Just in case you missed it, Speaking at a St James interfaith prayer breakfast a JDF Colonel Daniel George Pryce an intelligence officer told the congregation that demonic forces are influencing crime in St James, where a state of public emergency was imposed in January, and the authorities are not equipped to deal with it. If this wasn’t so retarded it would be laughable, this is the same JDF which has the lead over the ZOSO in the parish.This officer is an intelligence officer[sic]
Colonel Pryce…
“We wrestle not against flesh and blood. This war is not physical, and therefore it takes a spiritual response to this,” stated Colonel Pryce. Pryce, who said he was giving the address in two parts — as a soldier and as a Christian — noted that “me in a my uniform, the police in their uniform can’t take on the spiritual warfare”.
Pryce spoke to the number of Gangs operating in the community of Cambridge 29 to be exact, numbers supplied by the police of course. The Colonel mentioned demonic practices, such as Illuminati and Baphomet, engaged in by gangs. Most notably the gathering was by a supposed Church group which calls itself the Supernatural Encounter Jamaica (SEJ) .
Pryce pointed out that the gun was responsible for 253 of the 335 murders committed in the parish last year, and noted that the murder toll was the highest recorded in the country’s history for a police division. The figure equates to 67 more murders than were reported in 2016. Thank God for ZOSO Colonel Pryce said. There is that representation to ZOSO again.
“At this rate, we are almost at a civil war”. No Colonel Pryce, we are not almost in a civil war, we are in a state of civil war! That war will not be won by indulging in nonsensical belief in the occult. It will not be won by prayer and fasting. It will be won when the Jamaican Government gives the security forces the tools they need and get out of the way so that they may go after murderers rapists and other dangerous felons.
With illogical rantings of this kind, our country is not only destined to be the laughing stock of the Caribbean region we will be the laughing stock of the world, in addition to our high murder designation. The only supernatural force affecting crime is the ignorant and unexplained idiotic approach being applied to the Islands crime epidemic. It is intellectual rot, not Illuminati. If only the leaders would pull their heads from their own asses that much would be clear.
ATSOMEPOINTINTIMEWEHAVETOFACETHEFACTS, INDECOMISNOTANINDEPENDENTINVESTIGATIVEAGENCY, ITIS A GOVERNMENTANDFOREIGN-FUNDEDENEMYOFTHESECURITYFORCES…
Hamish Campbell and Terrence Williams
If (INDECOM) is not adhering to what was it’s stated mandated, then we must acknowledge that it is a rogue agencywhich is a black hole for tax-payers money. Under Terrence Williams and Hamish, Campbell INDECOM has morphed into a dangerous tool which encourages and brews dissent on the Island and emboldens Jamaica’s heavily armed criminal gangs.
The Government has a responsibility, in fact, its first duty is the security of the Jamaican people, that includes the Police. It is incumbent on the Government to either rein in Terrence Williams and Hamish Campbell or better yet disband this rogue agency which has become an enemy of the people.
This is the same old dilapidated office the commissioner of police, the Island’s top law enforcement calls his office.
According to INDECOM’s website: The Commission is funded by the Government of Jamaica from the consolidated fund. Since inception it has also received support by way of sponsorship from international partners: the Department for International Development (DFID), the United States International Narcotics and Law Enforcement (INL), European Union (EU) and Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA).
Even as INDECOM complains about dwindling funding coming from the Government, it’s own reporting indicates that the Jamaican Government continues to waste tremendous amounts of money on funding the Commission while the police do not have cars to answer citizens distress calls, Officers are forced to occupy filthy rat and roach infested ramshackle structures, which pass for police stations.
This is the INDECOM building in New Kingston Jamaica.…
Additionally, police stations have no computers, officers have no uniform or boots, and police officers cannot pay their bills. Even ass the IMF continue to heighten its calls for the Government to trim its public sector wage bill and teachers are on strike the government waste hundreds of millions of dollarseach year on an agency which produces nothing tangible for the Jamaican people.
inside INDECOM’S New Kingston digs…
The following figures represent the monies doled out to INDECOM by the Government and shadow overseas donors each year in an effort to antagonize, harass and demagogue the nation’s security forces.
2016/2017
GOJ: $366.492 million
Other: Donors $230.616 million
2017/2018
GOJ: $353.35 million
Other: $202.476 million
I ask Jamaicans to consider if these hundreds of millions of dollars are well spent on feeding the ego of Terrence Williams Hamish Campbell and others while 1616 of our countrymen and women were slaughtered last year and hundreds already dead so far this year? Jamaicans must demand answers from the Government, who gives money to INDECOM and why? What are their motives for giving these enormous sums of money to a commission which really does no law enforcement but lie in wait to persecute members of the security forces?
HEREARE A FEWOFWHATPASSESFORPOLICESTATIONS .…
The dilapidated structure that houses the Port Antonio Police Station in.St Mary.The antiquated and outdated Kingston central police station…Gold street police stationthe Withorn station Westmoreland.
The Wait-a-bit stationCitizens lend a hand to add a facelift to their station in Ramble Hanover.This is what passes for a police station in Linstead St Catherine..
Last year alone Jamaican Police reported that they investigated the death of 1616 of their fellow countrymen and women. This number represented an increase of about 20% in the homicide numbers reported to them the previous year. The astronomical number of deaths which are largely firearm related tells only a fraction of the carnage happening as it relates to crime and violence, as the number of those shot and injured are exponentially higher than those killed.
As the Government struggles to appear to be doing something through a series of haphazard measures, average law-abiding Jamaicans are at their wit’s end and are demanding drastic remedial actions. None of the actions, (ie) ZOSO zones of special operations law, the state of emergency in the parish of Saint James or any other stop-gap measure has had any meaningful impact on crime reduction.
The intractable crime conditions plaguing the Island had it’s Genesis in the 60’s and was nurtured and enhanced by the two political parties since then. We have gotten to the point now where violent crime is literally choking the lifeblood out of the country contrary to what the political leaders tell you, and they refuse to take the steps to stop it. It is remarkable that in a tiny country of 2.8 million people over 1600 could be murdered in a single year without a real sense of urgency anywhere.
With that said, there are structural carve-outs which if instituted could have a significant positive effect yet political considerations have hampered the implementation of commonsense approaches. Some of those common sense approaches include but are not confined to passing laws which puts dangerous criminals in prison and keep them there. Making the commitment to providing the support (legislatively and otherwise), equipment, and remunerations and of course proper training which are necessary for the police to do their jobs effectively. The Government cannot continue to refuse to support the efforts of law enforcement while pretending to do just that publicly. Governmental support for the police cannot be only to their parachuted friends that they place above the men and women of the department.
Terrence Williams Commissioner of INDECOM
More than anything else the Government can repeal the INDECOM Act! It must be clear to all except the willfully blind, that Terrence Williams is not an independent Investigator but a cheap media whore of a rabble-rouser. Commissioner Terrence Williams please see Independent Investigator(Robert Muller).
The overworked underpaid, under-equipped poorly supported police have been doing their best to deal with the onerous crime monster which is strangling the country with not much support for their efforts. Even as they do so Terrence Williams and Hamish Campbell sits on the sidelines and actively take actions to divert the attention of the country from the task at hand with a view to slime the police.
In addressing media entities the anti-police, foreign-funded government agency chose to slime the police through its commissioner and interloping assistant commissioner Hamish Campbell. Hamish Campbell outlined that 168 of the 264 shooting incidents reported against the security forces last year involved persons who were fatally shot. This, he said, represented an increase from 2016 when 111 of the 180 gun-related reports were for fatal shootings. In 2015, there were 169 shooting incidents.
“One measure of assessing police use of force and whether it may or may not be excessive is a distinction between those who are shot and injured and those who are killed,” Campbell said. “In Jamaica’s security forces, there are always significantly more people shot and killed than there are shot and injured; and it is for the JCF to reflect on those patterns.”
The job of INDECOM was sold to the nation as that of an independent agency which would “independently” investigate all incidents of police shootings as well as all allegations of abuse by the police, Military, and corrections departments. Since the JCF is the Agency in the public’s eye and is the very first agency tasked with dealing with those opposed to the rule of law it follows that the overwhelming bulk of the complaints would be against the Police.
Nevertheless, from its Genesis, the Commissioner of INDECOM has shown himself to be an attention seeking media whore who seems to go into withdrawal as a crack or opium addict does when he does not see his name in the news. Terrence Williams’ job is to find bad shootings and recommend charges. If his Agency cannot find anything wrong with the shootings, (shootings in which I might add police officers are shot and killed and injured) , why is Terrence Williams and Hamish Campbell allowed to slime the police with distorted data?
I once again call for the repeal of the INDECOM Act, we simply cannot have an agency partially funded by taxpayers money which is actively bent on subverting the role of the police, and enhancing anarchy in our country. INDECOM is an enemy of the people and by extension an enemy of our country. I call on the Jamaican people who care about crime, its time to demand an end to this farce. Demand a full repeal of the INDECOM act and the resources dedicated to training equipping and supporting the police in their fight for the soul of our country.
It’s time that this despicable modern-day Joe McCarthy be shown the door
When an offender is told he is under arrest that offender has every responsibility to submit to being arrested and have his day in court. If the officer is wrong, the arrestee has access to civil remedies under the laws. One thing is certain and should never be forgotten !!!!! When you decide to resist arrest you open yourself up to whatever is coming your way and you alone bear that burden. Simply put the officer has a right to arrest you if he believes you are committing an offense. You do not have the right to resist or fight with the officer. He has the right under the law to use force to gain your compliance.
Slapping away at officers and moving aggressively at officers trying to make an arrest is tolerated only in Jamaica. I write daily imploring officers to put down this kind of behavior rather quickly. My only problem with what the officer did was that he did not proceed to cuff him as soon as he was subdued.
It was 1982 I was a young constable at beat and foot, two of my colleagues were mobbed at South Parade, I went to their assistance, one woman grabbed me by my uniform shirt and ripped the buttons apart in the ensuing mêlée. I went to work with my baton and in short order, total order was restored, marched six people all holding each other’s clothes to Central. From that day onward until I left Beat and Foot whenever they saw me coming they parted like the red sea to Moses. I will move mountains for you, I signed on to ensure your safety but if put your hands on me and you will regret it. No Police officer signed up to be assaulted or killed doing their job.
I have been calling for these non-lethal tools to be given to the police and for supervisors to ensure that officers on the beat be in possession of them at all times. This kind of behavior simply has to stop. The Police MUST have the right to make arrests regardless of the offense, you do not get to fight a police officer and just walk away as if nothing happened.
One friend now lives in the United States, the other in a certain parish in Jamaica, both young men worked the land, one caught a break and left, the other remained. Back at home, they raised goats, burned charcoal and they eked and scratched out a living. The young man back at home still raises the goats, in fact, there were more goats. After all, now that his friend is able to send money back to purchase more goats. He still chopped wood, build the kilns, cut the grass, stacks the wood and burns the charcoal, all while having only one arm.
The young man in the States is hard working and respectful, a family man, he has been so since I first met him when he first came to the United States, he has remained so for the four years since he has been here. The story he tells me warmed my heart until it didn’t. His story gave me hope, true to my belief, not all of our young men are disposable, not all are bloodthirsty killers. But some definitely are.
While the young man in the States was working hard sending every spare dollar back to purchase the right Rams for siring the best kids, making sure the pens are secure and everything was in place, others were watching and biding their time. And so one day over a month ago as the man walked to his goat-farm they struck. Armed with guns they attacked, he fought valiantly using his machete to ward them off, but with only one arm, a machete and three more predators joining in, they quickly overpowered him.
They chopped and stabbed and chopped and stabbed, they even stabbed him in his eyes trying to gouge out them out. He eventually laid still, playing dead in a bid to save his life, what was left of it, if possible. They dragged him by the feet and dumped him in a ravine where they left him for dead, then they took the goats, all of them.
The badly mutilated man dragged himself bleeding profusely until he got to help. Well over a month later, he is unable to see from either of his eyes, even as he tries to recover from the vicious trauma inflicted on his body. As is to be expected no one has been arrested, this gruesome barbaric case didn’t even make the local news.
This begs the question, how many more innocent hard working people have been murdered simply for the sweat of their brow? How can we pretend that all is well when hard-working men who till the soil burn charcoal and raise some goats are treated this way simply because of the meager living they extract for their efforts.
This story is not dissimilar to the killing of 32-year-old Notoya Ricketts whose bullet-riddled body was found by residents in early February. Her two-year-old daughter, who was found next to the body, was not harmed. Miss Ricketts was last seen alive on the way to tend to her animals. Ms. Ricketts’s mother was murdered in the community just two weeks prior to her own death.
These are the types of gruesome killings and assaults which are not being covered in the news. As Tourism numbers are burnished and a new Commissioner of Police is set to take over, the question must be how do we stop this? The Police are seemingly incapable or unwilling to extend themselves to do what it takes. I can’t say I blame them frankly, the system is supportive of the killers, not those who work to remove them from society and to some degree the general population is highly supportive of criminal conduct.
We get the communities we want by our actions, that translates into the parishes and ultimately the country we end up with. Whether we admit it or not this desire to align with criminals to the peril of the rule of law will continue to have disastrous consequences for Jamaicans.
Those who shape and make policy can pretend that the foolhardy path they are on will result in a utopian elimination of crime as against a systematic and well-targeted attack on gangsters. Ultimately we will see the results, like a pregnancy there is a baby coming and we will all be forced to face the results.
Tulsa County Oklahoma officials settled a civil rights lawsuit on Friday when it agreed to pay the estate of Eric Harris $6 million after he was shot and killed in 2015 by a man so rich, county officials allowed him to literally play a game of cops and robbers.
The case made national headlines when Tulsa County officers invited 73-year-old Reserve Deputy Robert Bates along for a gun sting meant to ensnare Harris. Harris was chased down and subdued by officers when Bates, a wealthy insurance executive with an affinity for law enforcement, shot Harris in the armpit. Bates claimed that he mistook his gun for his Taser, but was sentenced to four years in prison for second-degree manslaughter.
Bates was deputized as a reserve officer by his a fishing partner and benefactor, Tulsa County Sherrif Stanley Glanz. Gates had donated vehicles and equipment items to the Sherrif’s Department and gave money to Glanz’s political campaigns, serving as the campaign manager during Glanz’s 2012 run for Sherrif.
The Harris family lawsuit sued Bates, Glanz, and four other officers for excessive force and civil rights violations. The civil suit alleged Glanz of “turned a blind eye to these dangers … to allow his friend and financial benefactor to ‘play cop’ in the streets of Tulsa County.” It also charges that Bates was improperly trained.
After the Harris shooting, an internal investigation found records that showed Bates’ training records were falsified and that the County pressured investigators to deem the use of force “justifiable.”
The $6 million settlement closes the civil case and bars the Harris estate from filing individual suits against the defendants in the case. The money will be paid out over three years, bringing the total cost of Bates’ cop cosplay to $6.6 million for the citizens of Tulsa County, according to the Tulsa World.
“It’s in the best interest of all parties involved to resolve these claims at this time,” Tulsa County Sherrif Vic Regalado said. “I believe this decision will allow the process of healing to continue for the Harris family, the citizens of Tulsa County and the hard-working men and women of the Tulsa County Sheriff’s Office.”
Glanz eventually resigned his office after he was charged with misdemeanor crimes in a subsequent investigation.
The appointment of Major General Anthony Anderson as Commissioner of Police in Jamaica should not be viewed in the narrow parochial way many of us tend to view issues. There has to be an acceptance in a fulsome way of the many sides to each and every issue. It is always better to air out ideas, giving equal time and attention to all sides before arriving at a conclusion.
Of course, those like myself who oppose Anderson’s appointment have no personal vendetta against the man, I don’t even know him. Neither am I on a personal crusade against the JDF as some closed-minded, intellectually challenged people are wont to accuse. Nevertheless, it is always easier to make ad hominem attacks rather than having the chutzpah to have an open debate on the merits.
Look, I could roll over and simply sing praise to General Anderson like Keith Trinity Gardner now an attorney at law and former Assistant Commissioner of Police, but I can’t, despite whatever successes I may have attained the elitist club in upper Saint Andrew was never on my bucket list.
Anderson
So I have a couple of suggestions to make (1) I would like to see former Commissioner of Police Carl Williams appointed Governor of the Bank of Jamaica. By the standard of thinking in Jamaica being supremely qualified in one discipline qualifies one to do every job right? Former Commissioner Dr.Carl William Ph.D. has an impressive record in law enforcement, particularly in the area of narcotics and he has written policy papers on crime in Jamaica, most notably ‘Consequences of the War on Drugs: The Jamaican Experience. http://digjamaica.com/blog/2014/09/09/who-is-police-commissioner-designate-carl-williams/
I’m not sure what Dr. Williams is doing these days but I say let’s remove the BOJ head and make him the Governor[sic]. While we are at it (2) Portia Simpson Miller has attained the highest executive office in our country, she is now out of work I’m sure Sista P would like to be back being useful so why not make her head of neurosurgery up there at Mona?
You see qualification is qualification so it does not matter if you have a liberal arts degree you are certainly qualified to fly an airplane right?[sic] What do you mean no? So you are saying whats good for the Goose isn’t good for the Gander? Oh, I see.….…So the fallacy of the Anderson appointment as the savior of policing in Jamaica just crumbled under the light of a little scrutiny.
Like I said I have zero desire to move to Upper St Andrew or rub shoulders with the largely pretentious hypocrites who live there. I have no desire to go to their little Kiwanis clubhouses, and I certainly do not crave their friendship. Sorry, Mister Keith Gardner. I certainly could buy a house where they live if I wanted to, by I’m a simple country boy from rural St, Catherine who like real people, and oh despite living in a foreign land since 1991 my Jamaican accent is still the same.
THEBOTTOMLINE
The bottom line is that Jamaica has resilient people many of whom have accomplished exceptional things particularly in the area of Education and Sports. Whatever we put our minds to we generally stand out and are easily identified. Unfortunately, there is another side of our Jamaican-ness the fame of Usain Bolt and Anthony Anderson is always countered by the infamy of our worst criminals.
As we celebrate the accomplishments of our best we have to be guarded that the actions of our worse are appropriately countered by the best trained, best experienced to do the job. We have to have the best doctors treating our sick, not the best bankers. We must have the best lawyers defending our interest in a court of law, not the best firemen.
Despite Anderson’s impressive resume,^ as a soldier, he is exactly that, a soldier, not a cop. The best indicator for a way forward is to look at precedent. Twice before have former heads been parachuted in to save the Constabulary with disastrous consequences. The best way to fix the Constabulary is to fix the constabulary. Imagine dragging an unwell pilot out of the cockpit and placing the flight attendant in his seat with the hope of a pleasant landing. If the Pilot cannot be resuscitated it’s up to the co-pilot to take over not the flight attendant. What is it in the history of the JDF which makes it’s ex-offices equipped to fix every problem in our country? From Football to the voting rolls to everything in between, I don’t get it?
Apart from the many years of training and education which goes into the elevation to the topmost positions in police departments the expertise garnered over the course of time is invaluable to the discipline. Even more consequential to the debate is the question of morale at the entry level. As I pointed out in a recent article, morale is particularly important in a job like the police force in which offers sub-standard remunerations, lack of political support, poor working conditions, lack and a shortage of equipment and tools and an overabundance of danger at all levels. That danger is ever present even when they do their jobs by the book in a country like Jamaica in which the justice system is heavily slanted toward the protection of criminals.
The idea that each constable can be commissioner has been a valuable carrot to the otherwise harsh stick of being a police officer in the hostile Jamaican working environment. Take that away and the harm will be catastrophic. At present, the police force struggles to attract enough new candidates to fill recruitment requirements. On the other hand, roughly 600 officers are walking away from the JCF each year.
The Minister of National Security recently bragged that fewer police officers are leaving the department which is actually laughable because under the recently passed ZOSO law the Government codified into law provisions which criminalize police officers for daring to leave the JCF without giving a 6‑month advanced notice to the department.
How the Minister is able to determine that fewer officers are leaving as a result of any strategy outside that draconian provision in the ZOSO law, given insufficient time for the data to be credible is beyond me. Former JDF head Hardly Lewin, who was also one of the firemen asked to do heart surgery[sic] claims Anthony Anderson will be successful because he has the support of the political directorate. His statement is confirmation of what I have personally believed and spoken to. The high crime rate is not a problem attributable to the police but a problem of a lack of legislative support so that officers may have a reasonable shot at getting it right.
When all is said and done, if we do not fix the areas of resources, legislative support, better pay, and respect for our police officers, crime will not ever decrease. You can pretend the problem is the police and point fingers in order to avoid responsibility. There may even be some silly officers past and present who believe the police will do better by having an overlord parachuted in. The fact of the matter is that there are some fundamental changes needed which has nothing to do with who sits in a chair at 103 Old Hope Road but with the 63 dimwits who bang on desks in that building on Duke Street.
Let’s establish some facts in this Machiavellian process of selecting a Commissioner of police presently before the Police Services Commission (PSC). (1) If the Prime Minister and or the Minister of National Security tells you they do not know who will be next Commissioner of police they are lying to you. (2) The Prime Minister knows who he wants to hold that office regardless of who applies. If you believe that a Commissioner of Police is ever going to be selected by the (PSC) and foisted onto the Prime Minister I have a bridge to sell you, in fact, I’ll throw in the flat bridge free of charge in the deal.
Furthermore, even if the Prime Minister and or the Minister of National Security did not have advanced knowledge of who would be selected, is there a single person alive who believes that the PM would not simply pick up the phone to speak to the head of the PSC to make his views known? These observations are not meant to criticize the PM for wanting whom he wants to be commissioner of police. Unlike many people, I believe that the Nation’s Prime Minister’s number one job is to keep the nation safe.
On that basis and that basis alone the Prime Minister, [regardless of party,] ought to have a free hand in selecting the best person in his/her estimation to execute whatever strategies he/she has for completing that mandate. I have no quarrel with a Commissioner of [police coming onboard with political connections, political connections and labels have not hindered them from doing their jobs effectively in other countries, it shouldn’t negate their potential in Jamaica.
HYPOCRISY
The idea that a Commissioner of Police will make much of a difference in Jamaica’s toxic environment is the epitome of naïveté ^. It’s the equivalence of sending a poorly equipped, untrained army to do battle with their hands tied behind their backs but nonetheless led by a newly minted General. To foist someone onto the police who has not come up through the ranks and have their trust and respect in my estimation is a clear sign that there is no intent to beginning the arduous task of rolling back violent crime.
If anyone believes that morale is an insignificant characteristic in bodies in which cohesion and stick-to-itiveness are required they are wrong. Believing that it can be disregarded in military and police forces is bordering on lunacy. There are two Prime Ministers who have led Jamaica who will be on my shit list forever. The two are Percival James Patterson of the PNP and Orett Bruce Golding of the JLP. The unmitigated truth in this blame game which has landed on the doorsteps of the police is that the department was never given the tools to succeed. Success for the JCF would have meant no illicit wealth for the Island’s political class after they were handed the reins of the country. The corruption in Jamaica has relatives in Africa, Central and South America and other colonized parts of the world. The new bosses were not about to embark on a process of law and order, they had to enrich themselves.
Neither men are solely responsible for crime in our country per se, but Patterson presided over the most dramatic period of rot in our culture which resulted in the greatest growth in lawlessness and violent crimes and the destruction of the JCF. Bruce Golding watched it happen and when he took office he did not have a plan to fix it, in fact, he took actions which had the opposite effect of fixing the problems, a‑la INDECOM et al, his tenure was particularly harmful to the rule of law. Jamaica was well served when he was forced to step aside.
The challenges facing the Constabulary will certainly not be remedied by changing the Commissioner, that’s like putting a shiny new cover on a leaky old pot. The structural deficiencies which the police department faces are inherently different than a teacher not having the requisite number of textbooks to effectively teach a class. Cops cannot answer calls if they have no cars.
One of the key ways in which I thought the police could improve its service delivery over the years has been in response time. People are consoled immensely when they have an idea that when they call the police the police is going to be there in quick time. As a citizen, there can be no greater fear than to be in trouble with no recourse or expectation of help coming from the police.
Over the years I have called for seniors to drive their own cars and leave the vehicles at the station to service the needs of the citizens they serve. I can tell you that as members of the CIB stationed at the Constant Spring Police Station Dadrick Henry and myself made it our duty to try to be at the scene as soon as was humanly possible after receiving directives from police control.
As consequence, citizens knew when Dadrick Henry and I were working because of our dedication to answering calls as quickly as possible. That area of police service delivery is only one component but it is a critical component in the reassurance of the people who depend on the police for their safety and security. It must be understood that when citizens cannot depend on the police to come to their rescue, to their defense, come to their aid, they are forced to acquiesce to the demands of the criminal underworld.
What we have seen over the last three decades in our country has been a paradigm shift in the loyalty of the populace from the police to the gangs and Dons. The reason for this is that this universe does not like vacuums if the police are unable to fill the security needs of the population they have to make friends with those they would not normally be friendly to. It is a matter of survival in many cases. I suggest that the next Commissioner of police look at response time as his/her first priority, this will go a long way in bringing some reassurance to a skeptical populace and would be an important deterrent to those who break our laws.
If the rumblings in the Jamaican press is true that Major General Anderson the nation’s first national security adviser is being tapped to be the next Commissioner of Police then I would suggest that members of the police force with any brain in their heads lay down arms and walk away.
Anderson and Holness
It would be the icing on the cake that this administration has zero respect for the men and women of the JCF, does not care about their many years of service and the fact that many are supremely and imminently academically qualified. In fact, there are serving members of the JCF who are supremely more qualified than the Nation’s Prime Minister, Andrew Holness.
We have not verified that this story is correct so we will withhold further comment at this time.
On March 1st, 2018 Michelle Alexander gave a Keynote Lecture at Marist College Nelly Goletti Theatre in Poughkeepsie New York, on the subject of mass incarceration of people of color in the United States. The Lecture was moderated by Dr. Tia Sheree Gaynor Assistant Professor of Public Administration and Dr. Joycelyn Smith-Lee Assistant Professor, of Psychology both African-Americans.
Dr.Gaynor left Dr. Smith Lee center and Ms. Alexander right.
I had the privilege of attending the lecture with my wife Cheryl and meeting Michelle Alexander a woman whose work I have admired. It was interesting to hear Ms. Alexander speak to her fears at the prospect of not being taken seriously in her advocacy. Michelle Alexander is a writer, civil rights advocate, and a visiting professor at Union Theological Seminary. She is best known for her 2010 book The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. Ms. Alexander spoke to her misgivings at the start of her social activism around the time then Illinois Senator Barack Obama was running to be President of the United States and the attendant feeling of euphoria which abounded at the time, particularly in the African-American community. Professor Alexander mused that before Obama was elected she thought to herself that if Obama was elected no one would listen to her griping about the broken racial system in America. She spoke about how difficult it was to get anyone to listen to her when she first broached the subject.
Ms. Alexander
Ms. Alexander talked about the beginning of her social activism at ACLU, there as an Attorney, she represented victims of racial bias. It is at this juncture of her life she revealed, that she had an awakening. She talked about whilst there she was constantly suing Police Departments in the State of California in the late 1990s for racial profiling or (DWB) driving while black a term which was not well known at the time. DWB was said to be a figment of people’s imagination according to Police and their supporters she quipped.
Michelle Alexander’s 2010 book the new Jim crow. Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness.
According to her, a hotline was set up so that victims of police abuse could report their encounters. The system crashed as a result of the volume of calls. One young black man had gone to great lengths to document the multiple times he was stopped by police, searched, roughed-up, made to lie spread-eagled on the sidewalk, and otherwise abused. His documentation including date and time, badge numbers of the offices involved in stacks and stacks of paper against the Oakland Police. Ms. Aleaxnder spoke to her sense of excitement at the prospect of representing this particular young man. And then he revealed that he was a felon.
My wife Cheryl posing with Ms. Alexander having bought her second book.
She contemplated how the narrative would be framed, how the police and media would frame the talking points around the vigilance of the police doing their jobs effectively by keeping tabs on a convicted drug felon. Who would care about her advocacy on this issue? The young man was enraged when she told him that she could not represent him.
Posing with Ms. Alexander after the lecture.
“I was framed they planted drugs on me I was forced to take a plea despite my innocence or risk going to prison for years”.“You are no different than the police he accused”, he tore up the sheets of detailed data he had documented and stormed out. According to Ms. Alexander seven months later a media report broke a news story naming the very same officer as having planted drugs on innocent young black and brown men. Michelle Alexander spoke at length on the state of justice in America, arguing that the Portugees model works better than the one we have here at home. Present at the lecture were individuals who did serious prison time as a result of America’s war on drugs and are now picking up the pieces of their lives in an effort to move on. Ms. Alexander bemoaned the way the crack epidemic was viewed as a punishment of criminals unworthy of empathy while the opioid epidemic is now viewed as a public health issue. The difference of course between the two being race.
A packed theater turned out to hear Michelle Alexander speak on March 1st.
After the lecture, Ms. Alexander signed copies of her book the new Jim crow, Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness, for those who brought their copies of her 2010 book to the lecture as well as for those who purchased copies of her book in the hallway. My wife and I stood in the long snaking line for what seemed an eternity before we finally got to her. She smiled and chatted with us as she did with everyone else. She was extremely gracious with her time even though it was well into the night.
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.