Fatal Police Shooting Of Startup Founder Puts Austin’s Diversity Problem In The Spotlight

Maybe this has noth­ing to do with diver­si­ty. Maybe , just maybe there is a large domes­tic mili­tia called the police with strict orders to kill, oper­at­ing as if the streets are a war­zone. Just maybe.
I recall hav­ing a con­ver­sa­tion some­time ear­li­er this year with a young Indian man who hap­pens to be a pros­e­cu­tor in New Jersey on the ques­tion of police excess­es. Listening to him, one would have walked away believ­ing there is no racism in America.
On the oth­er hand, the sys­tem has man­aged to con­vince the American peo­ple that unwar­rant­ed police vio­lence is unavoidable.
To an offi­cer trained in anoth­er coun­try, we know BS when we see it. We know that dis­cre­tion is the bet­ter part of val­or. We also know that the role of the police is not to kill sum­mar­i­ly but to be judi­cious asses­sors of events and make good deci­sions before using lethal force.
In a sit­u­a­tion like this one, the man they killed was wear­ing a robe, a clear sign that he is asso­ci­at­ed with the neigh­bor­hood and more specif­i­cal­ly a home nearby.
Additionally, there are over four hun­dred mil­lion guns in the hands of Americans, so this man most like­ly had a right to have the firearm he had in his hand.
Most impor­tant­ly, when a police offi­cer gives the order to drop a weapon it should not be a pre­cur­sor to jus­ti­fy mur­der; it should be a legit­i­mate com­mand to de-esca­late a sit­u­a­tion. American cops are using this order while they fire a bar­rage of bul­lets at American cit­i­zens and the courts are allow­ing them to get away with out­right mur­der in cold blood.
(mb)

YouTube player

.….….….….……

Rajan “Raj” Moonesinghe (right) and his broth­er Johann Moonesinghe (left) pic­tured with their cousin (cen­ter). Image Credits: Johann Moonesinghe. For years, Austin has made head­lines as an evolv­ing tech hub where star­tups, large com­pa­nies and investors alike have flocked to set up a pres­ence. But as 2022 clos­es, the Texas cap­i­tal is in the news for a very dif­fer­ent, trag­ic rea­son — being home to the sud­den death of a start­up founder at the hands of a police offi­cer. On November 15, inKind co-founder Rajan “Raj” Moonesinghe was fatal­ly shot out­side of his south Austin home in what his fam­i­ly and col­leagues describe as a sense­less acci­dent that could have been avoided.

The 33-year-old had returned from a two-week trip to dis­cov­er that things looked out of place in his home, accord­ing to his broth­er, Johann. The afflu­ent neigh­bor­hood had recent­ly become a tar­get for crim­i­nals — to the point that one home­own­er had felt so unsafe after being robbed that she moved out. The new own­ers proac­tive­ly hired 24-hour-secu­ri­ty to stand guard in front of their house. A few weeks pri­or, Moonesinghe had pur­chased an assault rifle to pro­tect him­self should a bur­glar attempt to enter his home. In what would turn out to be a sad­ly prophet­ic warn­ing, his neigh­bor and inKind COO El Khattary had cau­tioned, “A brown man with a big gun does­n’t get the ben­e­fit of the doubt.”

It turns out he had rea­son to be concerned.

Moonesinghe had report­ed­ly talked ear­li­er with his neigh­bor across the street, express­ing con­cern that some­one might be in his home, and retrieved his rifle as he looked around his prop­er­ty. With his front door open, Moonesinghe yelled for who­ev­er might be in his home to get out. He also shot his rifle into the home. The neighbor’s secu­ri­ty guard called 911.

According to Moonesinghe’s broth­er, Ring cam­era footage showed police arriv­ing at his brother’s prop­er­ty with no sirens or lights, with one of the offi­cers fatal­ly shoot­ing Raj.

The police didn’t announce them­selves or give him time to put the gun down,” Johann told TechCrunch. (A video of the inci­dent can be seen here. Warning: It may be inap­pro­pri­ate for some viewers.) 

The offi­cers said they per­formed life-sav­ing mea­sures on Raj, before he was ulti­mate­ly pro­nounced dead at a local hospital.

It was two days lat­er, though, before Raj’s fam­i­ly knew what hap­pened to him. The police at first held a press con­fer­ence, say­ing that “a white man” had been shot but did not dis­close details.

We were super con­fused,” Johann said. “We knew the cops were there, and we couldn’t get a hold of Raj. At first we thought it was him, and then we thought it wasn’t. They said they killed a white man who had been shoot­ing up the neigh­bor­hood. We didn’t know what to think.”

The inci­dent took place at 12:30 am on Tuesday, November 15. But the Moonesinghe fam­i­ly claim they were not noti­fied by police of Raj’s death until the evening of Thursday, November 17.

Raj was awe­some, absolute­ly phe­nom­e­nal. He just went out of his way to help oth­er peo­ple,” Johann told TechCrunch. “This is the worst thing that has ever hap­pened to me and my fam­i­ly. The hard­est part for me is that it was avoidable.”

We’re lucky that we have a very strong fam­i­ly, incred­i­ble friends and super sup­port­ive peo­ple around us,” he con­tin­ued. “It’s not only hard to lose some­body you love, but it’s dou­bly, triply hard because of the way the police han­dled it.”

TechCrunch reached out to the Austin Police Department (APD) and was referred to a December 1 press release stat­ing the depart­ment con­tin­ued to inves­ti­gate the shooting.

At the top of the release, Raj was described as a deceased Middle Eastern male. In the body of the release, the APD said the 911 caller had described a man with a gun “as a white male, wear­ing a grey robe and dark pants.”

In that release, the police depart­ment iden­ti­fied Officer Daniel Sanchez as the indi­vid­ual who fatal­ly shot Raj. Sanchez is report­ed­ly on admin­is­tra­tive leave pend­ing the depart­men­t’s inves­ti­ga­tions. In its state­ment, APD said that it would con­duct two con­cur­rent inves­ti­ga­tions into the inci­dent — a crim­i­nal inves­ti­ga­tion con­duct­ed by the APD Special Investigations Unit in con­junc­tion with the Travis County District Attorney’s Office, and an admin­is­tra­tive inves­ti­ga­tion con­duct­ed by the APD Internal Affairs Unit, with over­sight from the Office of Police Oversight.

After mov­ing to Austin about five years ago, inKind this year leased 22,000 square feet of office space that was Facebook’s first office in Austin. Business is going well, accord­ing to Johann. The start­up, which launched in 2016 by fund­ing restau­rants by pur­chas­ing large amounts of food and bev­er­age cred­its upfront, has raised $27 mil­lion in growth equi­ty and $130 mil­lion in debt over the past year and has about 74 employ­ees. It’s oper­at­ing at a $48 mil­lion run rate, Johann said.

What makes me real­ly sad is that star­tups are very, very hard, and Raj worked so hard for years and years. And now that the com­pa­ny is real­ly on a rock­et ship, he’s not here to enjoy that,” he added.

Johann told TechCrunch he also feels “guilty” because of the deci­sion sev­er­al years ago to move the start­up he helped co-found with his broth­er, Andrew Harris, Matt Saeta and Miles Matthias to Austin from Washington, D.C. An ear­ly investor in Uber and Twilio, Johann said he was hop­ing to relo­cate to a state with­out tax­es. Seattle and Miami were also considered.

Obviously the shoot­ing was not my fault,” Johann told TechCrunch. “But I don’t believe this would have hap­pened in anoth­er place. I’m gay and brown, grew up in LA, and lived a long time in D.C. The only time I have ever expe­ri­enced racism was when I moved to Austin.” While the broth­ers’ fam­i­ly is from Sri Lanka, the pair were born in Los Angeles.

Khattary told TechCrunch he views the city’s lack of diver­si­ty as “a weird thing” con­sid­er­ing its so-called pro­gres­sive rep­u­ta­tion, and called police treat­ment of peo­ple of col­or “dis­heart­en­ing.” For exam­ple, dur­ing the Black Lives Matter protests in 2020, 19 offi­cers were accused of seri­ous­ly injur­ing pro­tes­tors. Earlier this year, the offi­cers were indict­ed for using exces­sive force.

Clearly, there’s some­thing in Austin and Black Lives Matter in 2020 high­light­ed a lot of it,” he told TechCrunch. “This is a nation­wide prob­lem but Austin def­i­nite­ly has more than its fair share. In this case, the offi­cer per­ceived him [Raj] as a major threat and didn’t give him a chance.”

The con­trast between the city’s pro­gres­sive­ness and a pop­u­la­tion that is most­ly “very hos­pitable” and inci­dents such as this one can be hard for out­siders to grasp, Johann said.

I don’t think there’s overt racism. It’s more uncon­scious bias­es, with peo­ple mak­ing judge­ments around oth­ers in a split sec­ond,” he added. “And that’s real­ly prob­lem­at­ic. I do believe that if Raj were white, he prob­a­bly would­n’t have been killed.”

Austin’s lack of diver­si­ty is not a new prob­lem. As TechCrunch report­ed in March, the per­cent­age of Black res­i­dents, for exam­ple, steadi­ly decreased over time to an esti­mat­ed 7% in 2020. Many of Austin’s neigh­bor­hoods resem­ble those seen in Silicon Valley, with large­ly white and Asian res­i­dents and far few­er Hispanic and Black people.

Johann doesn’t want his broth­er to have died in vain. While he says he cur­rent­ly doesn’t “feel safe” in Austin and that it’s hard for him to con­sid­er ask­ing oth­er peo­ple to move here, he also knows that they can’t just move inKind. 

Instead, he’s hop­ing to help change Austin “to make it a place that’s safe for everyone.”

I hope that the Austin police even start the dia­logue, give us some answers and explain to us what they’re going to do dif­fer­ent­ly so this doesn’t hap­pen again,” Johann said.

He also wants to poten­tial­ly raise cap­i­tal that would go toward specif­i­cal­ly invest­ing in com­pa­nies that through data, improved secu­ri­ty cam­eras and oth­er tech could pos­si­bly help pre­vent what hap­pened to Raj from hap­pen­ing to others.