The Cruel Irony Which Is The Tivoli Gardens Inquiry…

mb
MB

So the Tivoli Report is out; final­ly, after a report­ed M$367 expen­di­ture, the three-mem­ber pan­el has made its find­ings known to the Parliament. I have not seen the report, and as such, I am restrained in my com­ments except on some salient points pub­lished in the Jamaican media.
Before I go into specifics, though, I won­der what could have been done with M$367 mil­lion out­side the colos­sal waste of this inquiry? Well, I take that back one man’s waste is anoth­er man’s trea­sure; the fool and his mon­ey will soon part.
And, the part they have.
In January 2015, Desmond McKenzie, the Member of Parliament for west Kingston, said that the com­mis­sion’s Chairman, Bajan, David Simmons, was being paid more than M$52.
Simmons, who came to Jamaica with an air of supe­ri­or­i­ty, cer­tain­ly will not need to wor­ry about mon­ey for the rest of his life. He can go back home to Barbados ghet­to rich and resume life as an hon­orary white man of the British Empire.
While we are at it, let David Simmons take some of Jamaica’s crim­i­nals back to his native Barbados, he seemed to like crim­i­nals and their way of life when he lived off the Jamaican dime. Let him take them back to Barbados and see how that turns out for them and him. As my grand aunt would say, “pop­py show.”

David Simmons, chief commissioner for the Tivoli Enquiry
David Simmons, chief com­mis­sion­er for the Tivoli Inquiry.

At the time, McKenzie called for an end to the inquiry argu­ing, ” We need to know how much mon­ey it cost the coun­try so far to put up the com­mis­sion­er, what is his phone bill, what is his food bill, and how much mon­ey to rent the con­fer­ence cen­ter and how much mon­ey for the sup­port staff, all that was not in the dis­clo­sure, and we need to know now.”
At the same time, Desmond McKenzie made those state­ments; he revealed a rather poignant truth about his think­ing. It should have giv­en pause to any per­son who serves in the secu­ri­ty forces or their fam­i­ly mem­bers who love and sup­port them.

As some­one who writes for the con­sump­tion of read­ers across oceans and not just Jamaica, I found the mem­ber of par­lia­men­t’s words rather telling.
When will the peo­ple get the oppor­tu­ni­ty to point out a police or a sol­dier? Over one week of oper­a­tion, do you want to tell me that not one police offi­cer or sol­dier has been arrest­ed and charged for any offense against the peo­ple? You want to tell me that the behav­ior was so good that nobody down there can com­plain about their actions?”
Haha…
So there you have it, the ene­my was not Christopher Dudus Coke, the inter­na­tion­al crim­i­nal. In Desmond McKenzie’s mind, the peo­ple we ought to be look­ing to imprison are the sol­diers and police offi­cers. But who is sur­prised by this? Both Political par­ties are lit­tle more than crim­i­nal enterprises.

Desmond McKenzie
Desmond McKenzie

TRADITIONAL DISTRACTION

Much of the talk among the pub­lic seeks to cov­er or deflect atten­tion away from the events of 2010, which was the great­est threat against the con­sti­tut­ed Jamaican state in his­to­ry. A crim­i­nal Kingpin and his mer­ce­nar­ies picked up arms in a trea­so­nous assault against the Jamaican state. That alone should give pause to the blind par­ti­sans, but it doesn’t.
They deflect atten­tion from that momen­tous and crit­i­cal­ly-telling event, by cre­at­ing a kan­ga­roo pan­el to cre­ate a doc­u­ment telling us how bad­ly the secu­ri­ty forces operated.
No men­tion of the crit­i­cal and hor­rif­ic sequence of events that neces­si­tat­ed the actions in the first place. What they do is come up with sug­ges­tions of com­pen­sa­tion to the peo­ple who for decades encour­aged, nur­tured, and pro­tect­ed the type of crim­i­nal­i­ty which bred not just that indi­vid­ual king­pin Christopher (dudus) Coke, but an entire fam­i­ly and lin­eage of oth­er kingpins.
Regardless of polit­i­cal affil­i­a­tion, every Jamaican should be offend­ed by this, but they won’t be.
It’s the police and mil­i­tary’s fault. Please send them to prison.

Sergeant Wayne Henriques... Constable Jason Davis, both of the Motorised Patrol Division brutally slaughtered along Mountain View Avenue.
Sergeant Wayne Henriques& Constable Jason Davis, both of the Motorized Patrol Division, were bru­tal­ly slaugh­tered along Mountain View Avenue.

Hannah Town police station burned.
Hannah Town police sta­tion burned.

♦Was it the police’s fault why the sta­tions were burned? ♦ Was it the police’s fault that police sta­tions were strafed with high-pow­ered weapons? ♦Was it the police’s fault that Max and his col­league were slaugh­tered? ♦ Was it the police’s fault why the com­mu­ni­ty of Tivoli Gardens was bar­ri­cad­ed and made a ver­i­ta­ble fortress? ♦Was it the police who pre­vent­ed com­mu­ni­ty mem­bers from leav­ing the com­mu­ni­ty, or was it the trea­so­nous mer­ce­nar­ies? ♦ Was it the secu­ri­ty forces that turned that com­mu­ni­ty and oth­ers like it into vir­tu­al states with­in Jamaica, out­side the con­trol of the rule of law?♦ Was it the police who divid­ed up the Island into war­ring fac­tions pit­ting broth­ers against broth­ers and sis­ter against sis­ter, or was it the politi­cians you worship?

The Darling Street Police Station
The Darling Street Police Station

Attack on State - Police stations set ablaze as mercenaries openly parade with high-powered weapons...
Attack on State — Police sta­tions set ablaze as mer­ce­nar­ies open­ly parade with high-pow­ered weapons…

The Island's justice Minister Delroy Chuck ,. Just open the vaults and pay up, oh apologize as well...
The Island’s jus­tice Minister Delroy Chuck,
Just open the vaults, pay up, and apol­o­gize as well…

Apologize to the peo­ple and pay them, the sit­ting min­is­ter of jus­tice tells the admin­is­tra­tion of which he is a key component.

Such is the coun­try Jamaica; this is what they want to hide from International scruti­ny while telling investors to come and telling dias­po­ra mem­bers to return home to live out their lives.
What I find laugh­able yet instruc­tive is that many of the pro­po­nents of the luna­cy are, like myself, com­par­a­tive­ly secure in adopt­ed coun­tries while advo­cat­ing a regres­sive view that has had dev­as­tat­ing con­se­quences for the coun­try since 1962.

Whenever the seri­ous issue of crime comes up, they come up with a smoke screen: “the police are cor­rupt.” It is s straw man excuse that has worked for both polit­i­cal par­ties and their apol­o­gists since day one. Please show me a police depart­ment that does not have offi­cers with bad char­ac­ter, and I say wel­come to Utopia. We can elim­i­nate bad cops and hon­or the good ones; we are not play­ing that hate game with you.
Let’s dis­pense with the bull­shit the schools of high­er learn­ing are insti­tu­tions of anti-police pro­pa­gan­da and anarchy.
For self-right­eous apol­o­gists who want to talk about police cor­rup­tion, let’s talk. Still, I will also talk about your earth­ly polit­i­cal Gods and their cor­rupt­ing influ­ences on the nation.
Let’s talk about the crim­i­nal lawyers who actu­al­ly give new mean­ing to the term “crim­i­nal lawyers.”
Let us talk about some of the cor­rupt judges and oth­er pub­lic servants.
If you want to talk about the cor­rup­tion on the Island, let us do so, but let us include every­one, not scape­goat the poor police, you hyp­ocrites. Let us have that con­ver­sa­tion now.

Portia Simpson Miller the former Prime Minister initiated the inquiry for purely political reasons.
The for­mer Prime Minister, Portia Simpson Miller, ini­ti­at­ed the inquiry for polit­i­cal reasons.

Others come up with con­vo­lut­ed alter­na­tive met­rics to con­vince them­selves and the gullible that the crime mon­ster on the Island is com­pa­ra­ble to America, the default adver­sary they love to hate, just not their dollar…
Yet I have spo­ken to police offi­cers, past and present, who have served in depart­ments across the coun­try, many of whom nev­er need­ed to remove their ser­vice weapons from their hol­sters their entire career.
My neigh­bor is one of them. So go ahead and con­vince your­selves that America is just as vio­lent as Jamaica.
Most offi­cers who leave the JCF and con­tin­ue a life in law enforce­ment in oth­er coun­tries do so with dis­tinc­tion. Those depart­ments respect and hon­or what they do.
Others like myself who chose dif­fer­ent careers after leav­ing do well for themselves.
Wherever Jamaicans live abroad, they dare not assault police offi­cers, nei­ther phys­i­cal­ly nor ver­bal­ly. They know bet­ter, so they leave that bull­shit at the Donald Sangster and the Norman Manley International air­ports before they leave.
Those who for­get find their sor­ry ass­es back on the next flight. Even with­in the CARICOM com­mu­ni­ty, oth­er Islands have none of it. Threats of boy­cotts and law­suits will not change the atti­tudes of Jamaica’s neigh­bors, who do not want Jamaicans and their crim­i­nal cul­ture in their coun­tries and do not want Jamaica to add to their crime sta­tis­tics even with much crime.
Rather telling.

Following the crim­i­nal politi­cian’s play­book by mak­ing scape­goats of the Island’s secu­ri­ty forces makes goats of those so fooled.
.
.

.

.

.

Mike Beckles is a for­mer Police Detective, busi­ness­man, free­lance writer, black achiev­er hon­oree, and cre­ator of the blog mike​beck​les​.com.